Difficulty: Medium
Correct Answer: It being a pleasant evening
Explanation:
Introduction / Context:
This sentence improvement question examines whether you can correct a common error in the use of participial phrases. The sentence tries to show a reason or circumstance for going out for a long drive. However, the beginning phrase is grammatically incomplete and creates what is often called a dangling participle. You must choose the option that introduces the sentence correctly and clearly.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Original sentence: (Being a pleasant evening), we went out for a long drive on a highway.
- Options: As a pleasant evening, It being a pleasant evening, With a pleasant evening, No improvement.
- The idea is that the evening was pleasant, so we decided to go for a drive.
Concept / Approach:
A participial phrase like being a pleasant evening must be logically connected to a noun that it describes. In the original structure, it seems to describe we, which is incorrect because people are not evenings. To avoid this dangling participle, we introduce a dummy subject it to stand for the time or weather, and make the phrase it being a pleasant evening, which correctly links the description to the situation. This construction is standard in English when giving a reason based on time or weather.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Step 1: Identify that being a pleasant evening is not attached to any clear subject in the original sentence and therefore hangs loosely.
Step 2: Recognise that the intended meaning is because it was a pleasant evening we went out for a long drive.
Step 3: Examine option A, As a pleasant evening. This does not form a complete clause and sounds unnatural, because an evening cannot by itself act as a subject doing something.
Step 4: Examine option B, It being a pleasant evening. This introduces it as the subject for being, clearly referring to the time or weather, and sets a proper causal background for the action we went out.
Step 5: Examine option C, With a pleasant evening. This suggests some kind of accompaniment and does not express the causal idea properly.
Step 6: Examine option D, No improvement, which is not acceptable because the original phrase is grammatically faulty.
Verification / Alternative check:
Insert each option into the sentence and read it aloud. As a pleasant evening, we went out for a long drive is incorrect, because the phrase wrongly describes we. With a pleasant evening, we went out also sounds awkward and unclear. It being a pleasant evening, we went out for a long drive on a highway sounds natural and properly connects the pleasant evening with the decision to go out. This confirms that option B is the best improvement.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
As a pleasant evening is wrong because it treats the evening as if it were acting like a person in the main clause.
With a pleasant evening is wrong because it does not clearly introduce the cause and is not the usual way to express this idea in English.
No improvement is wrong because the original sentence contains a dangling participle and is not acceptable in formal writing.
Common Pitfalls:
Dangling participles are a frequent source of errors in exams. Learners sometimes begin sentences with phrases like walking down the road or being a pleasant evening without providing a clear subject for these actions or states. To avoid this, always check that the noun immediately following the participial phrase is the one logically performing the action or being described. In time and weather expressions, using structures like it being a pleasant evening or as it was a pleasant evening is a safe and standard choice.
Final Answer:
The correct improvement is: It being a pleasant evening, we went out for a long drive on a highway.
Discussion & Comments