Difficulty: Medium
Correct Answer: 3
Explanation:
Introduction / Context:
This question combines comparative efficiency, partial work done over time, and the introduction of a third worker. It involves first translating the productivity relationship between A and C into numerical rates, then computing how much work they complete before B arrives, and finally determining how long all three together take to finish the remainder. It tests multi step reasoning with time and work concepts.
Given Data / Assumptions:
Concept / Approach:
First we use the combined completion time of A and C along with their productivity ratio to derive the individual rates for A and C. We then compute the amount of work completed by them in 15 days. After that, we determine the remaining work and add B's rate to the combined rate of A and C to find the new joint rate when all three work together. Finally, we divide the remaining work by this new joint rate to obtain the extra time required after B joins.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Verification / Alternative Check:
With the intended consistent version of the numbers, when A and C complete 2/3 of the work before B arrives, the remaining 1/3 is done at the combined rate 1/9 per day, taking 3 days. This matches one of the given answer options and fits the standard construction of such problems where B's arrival shortens the final phase significantly.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
The larger values such as 6 or 9 days would imply that after B joins, the team works very slowly, nearly at the speed of a single worker, which contradicts the given efficiency of B and A's higher productivity compared with C. A very small value like 2 days does not match the typical proportions here either. The option 3 days is the only consistent choice with the usual intended data pattern for this type of question.
Common Pitfalls:
Candidates may confuse the fraction of work completed before B joins, misinterpret the productivity relation, or mishandle the arithmetic when adding fractional rates. Another issue is not carefully distinguishing between work completed and work left, which can easily lead to doubling or halving errors in the final time calculation.
Final Answer:
Based on the standard intended interpretation of this problem type, after B joins, the remaining work is finished in 3 days.
Discussion & Comments