Difficulty: Medium
Correct Answer: 1 : 3
Explanation:
Introduction / Context:
This is a geometry and trigonometry hybrid problem involving a regular hexagon and angles of elevation. By using properties of a regular hexagon and basic tangent definitions, we can relate the horizontal distances from A to B and from A to C with the heights of the towers placed at those vertices. Such questions appear in height and distance sections of aptitude exams, often combined with polygon properties.
Given Data / Assumptions:
Concept / Approach:
In a regular hexagon of side length s, each side is equal, and all interior angles are 120°. If the hexagon is inscribed in a circle, the central angle between adjacent vertices is 60°. The distances AB and AC can be expressed in terms of the side length s. Then, using tan(angle) = height / horizontal distance, we can write h_B and h_C in terms of s and the given angles. Finally, dividing h_B by h_C eliminates s and gives the required ratio.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Let the side length of the regular hexagon be s.
Then AB = s, because adjacent vertices are one side apart.
Vertices of a regular hexagon on a circle are 60° apart at the center.
The distance AC corresponds to a chord that spans two sides, that is, 120° at the center.
For a circle of radius R, chord length for 60° is AB = 2R sin 30° = R, so s = R.
Chord length for 120° is AC = 2R sin 60° = 2R * (sqrt(3) / 2) = R sqrt(3) = s sqrt(3).
Now use tangents for the right triangles formed with vertical heights.
tan 30° = h_B / AB = h_B / s.
So h_B = s * tan 30° = s * (1 / sqrt(3)) = s / sqrt(3).
tan 45° = h_C / AC = h_C / (s sqrt(3)).
Since tan 45° = 1, we have h_C = s sqrt(3).
Therefore, h_B : h_C = (s / sqrt(3)) : (s sqrt(3)).
Cancel s from both terms: h_B : h_C = 1 / sqrt(3) : sqrt(3).
Multiply numerator and denominator by sqrt(3) to simplify: 1 : 3.
Verification / Alternative check:
You can assign a convenient value to s to check the ratio numerically. For example, let s = sqrt(3). Then AB = sqrt(3) and AC = 3. From A, h_B = AB * tan 30° = sqrt(3) * (1 / sqrt(3)) = 1. Also, h_C = AC * tan 45° = 3 * 1 = 3. Thus h_B : h_C = 1 : 3, matching the algebraic result.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
1 : sqrt(3) would be the ratio if h_C were s rather than s sqrt(3). 1 : 2 and 1 : 2sqrt(3) do not arise from the geometry and correspond to incorrect distance assumptions. sqrt(3) : 1 is the inverse of the correct ratio and would imply h_B is taller than h_C, which contradicts the angles of elevation (45° for C should correspond to a relatively taller or closer tower than 30° for the same horizontal scale).
Common Pitfalls:
A frequent error is to assume AC = 2s instead of s sqrt(3). Another mistake is to forget that the angle of elevation is measured from A to the top of each tower, not from the center of the hexagon. Using wrong chord lengths or misapplying tangent formulas will quickly lead to incorrect ratios. Drawing a rough diagram often helps to visualise the relationships.
Final Answer:
The ratio of the heights of the towers at B and C is 1 : 3.
Discussion & Comments