1. Statement: Residents from Model Colony coming under North Ward of City X have complained to the Ward Officer that for last three days the tap water in the ward is contaminated and no action is being initiated by municipal staff.
Courses of Action:
The Ward Officer of North Ward should initiate action against residents who have lodged complaints against municipal staff.
The Ward Officer should ask his junior officer to visit Model Colony to assess the actual condition of water with his staff and to get samples of water tested from laboratories.
The Ward Officer should ask Ward Engineer to check water installations and pipelines in the Model Colony area.
The residents complained to the Ward Officer regarding the negligence of duty of his subordinates. So, I does not follow. Also, it is the moral duty of the Officer to listen to the complaints, ascertain the quality of water in the colony and get all pipelines and connections checked for any damage or leak that could have opened the way for contamination of water. Thus, both II and III follow.
2. Statement: People residing in some tribal areas are far from education.
Courses of Action:
Government should render all help to the NGOs to open schools there.
A mass awareness programme must be initiated in these areas.
Social workers should be entrusted with the job of educating them.
Clearly, people in tribal areas ought to be made aware of the need of education and persuaded to send children to schools. But at the same time proper facilities to render education must also be available. So, both I and II follow. However, education by social workers shall be a temporary remedy. Thus, III does not follow.
3. Statement: The exodus from villages to cities is detrimental to both.
Courses of Action:
Rural postings must be made mandatory.
There should be fewer trains linking cities to smaller places.
Employment generation scheme should be launched in rural areas.
Clearly, the exodus cannot be stopped by reducing the number of trains. So, II does not follow. The exodus occurs primarily due to better employment opportunities and facilities in the cities. Hence, it can be prevented not by compulsion but by making conditions favourable for those residing in villages. So, I does not follow while III follows.
4. Statement: Major part of the rabi crop in the district is damaged due to unseasonal heavy rains during the last few days.
Courses of Action:
The government should grant relief to the affected farmers to compensate their loss.
The government should provide free seed and fertilizer to the farmers for the kharif season.
The government should waive all the loans taken for the rabi crop by the affected farmers.
Clearly, the owner of the shop should be punished for selling spurious liquor. Further, attempts should be made to unearth other such unscrupulous liquor sellers by conducting raids and testing samples collected from different shops. So, both II and III follow. However, sending the liquor shop owner to another place may create a problem elsewhere also. So, II does not follow.
6. Statement: Every year thousands of eligible students do not get admission in colleges both in urban and rural areas after passing their school leaving certificate examination.
Courses of Action:
More colleges should be set up in both urban and rural areas.
The number of schools in both urban and rural areas should be reduced.
More schools should offer vocational courses to equip students for taking up their vocation after completing their school education.
The solution to the problem lies in accommodating the increasing number of students passing out from schools. So, only I and III follow.
7. Statement: According to the officials, paucity of funds with the organisation has led to the pathetic condition of this brilliant architectural structure.
Courses of Action:
Anew architectural structure for the building should be designed.
The reasons for the poor condition of the structure should be found out.
Grant should be given to improve the condition of the structure.
The statement asserts that the structure was originally a 'brilliant' one. So, there is no need of a new architectural design, as mentioned in I. Also, it is given that paucity of funds is responsible for the dilapidated condition of the structure. Thus, only III follows while II doesn't.
8. Statement: Nuclear power cannot make a country secure.
Courses of Action:
We must stop further expenses on increasing our nuclear power.
We must destroy our nuclear capability.
We must concentrate on improving our diplomatic relations.
The statement asserts that increasing defensive power does not ensure the safety of a country. It is equally important to maintain good relations with other countries as well. But this does not imply that the country should stop concentrating on increasing defensive power or destroy the existing power. Thus, only III follows.
9. Statement: There has been an unprecedented increase in use of malpractices by the students during various examinations held in the country this year.
Courses of Action:
All the concerned authorities conducting these examinations should immediately take effective measures to curb this menace.
All those students who are detected to have used unfair means should be debarred from appearing in any of these examinations for the next three years.
Using unfair means should immediately be made cognizable offence by passing necessary legislations.
Use of malpractices does away with the basic essence of examinations and hence it ought to be checked. So, I follows. Also, the fear of harsh punishments would prevent students from using unfair means. So, II also follows. But declaring it a crime may spoil the career of students who are caught using unfair means. So, III does not follow.
10. Statement: In one of the worst accidents in railway level crossing, fifty people died when a bus carrying them collided on to a running train.
Courses of Action:
The train driver should immediately be suspended.
The driver of the bus should be tried in court for negligence on his part.
The railway authority should be asked to man all its level crossings.
The problem discussed in the statement is not regarding the current accident, but to do something to avert such mishaps. Accidents at railway crossings can be averted by deploying men to regulate traffic and installing barriers to check traffic movement when a train passes by. So, only III follows.