Differential pressure flowmeters: compared with a venturimeter, the permanent power/pressure loss across an orificemeter is generally
-
ALess than that in a venturimeter
-
BApproximately the same as that in a venturimeter
-
CMore than that in a venturimeter
-
DUnpredictable with available data
-
EZero in both devices
Answer
Correct Answer: More than that in a venturimeter
Explanation
Introduction:Venturimeters and orificemeters are classic differential-pressure flowmeters. While both create a pressure drop to infer flow rate, their hydraulic recoveries differ markedly, impacting pumping cost and energy efficiency.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Incompressible, steady flow.
- Meters correctly installed and sized.
- Focus is on permanent (unrecovered) pressure loss.
Concept / Approach:A venturimeter accelerates then smoothly decelerates the fluid through a converging–throat–diverging nozzle, enabling high pressure recovery. An orificemeter has a sharp-edged plate causing flow separation and a vena contracta downstream, with large mixing losses and poor pressure recovery, resulting in higher permanent loss.
Step-by-Step Solution:Both devices create a differential pressure ∆p for metering.Venturi: streamlined diffuser recovers much of the kinetic energy → small permanent loss.Orifice: separated flow and turbulence → low recovery → large permanent loss.Therefore, orificemeter loss > venturimeter loss.
Verification / Alternative check:Manufacturer data and handbooks show typical loss coefficients: orifices may lose 50–70% (or more) of ∆p, while venturis often recover most, leaving a small residual loss.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Less than/same as: contradict well-known recovery differences.
- Unpredictable: qualitative ranking is well established.
- Zero: no real meter is lossless.
Common Pitfalls:Confusing differential pressure used for measurement with permanent loss. The two are related but not identical; geometry controls recovery.
Final Answer:More than that in a venturimeter