Which one of the following is NOT considered an instrument of fiscal policy used by the government to influence the economy?

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: Open market operations in government securities

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
Fiscal policy instruments are tools related to government revenue and expenditure, whereas monetary policy instruments relate to money and credit. In exams, you are often asked to distinguish between these two sets of tools. This question asks which of the listed items is not an instrument of fiscal policy, that is, which one belongs instead to monetary policy.


Given Data / Assumptions:
- The options include open market operations, taxation, public borrowing and public expenditure.
- Fiscal policy is carried out by the government (for example, the Ministry of Finance).
- Monetary policy is carried out by the central bank (for example, the Reserve Bank of India).


Concept / Approach:
Taxation, public borrowing and public expenditure clearly fall under the domain of fiscal policy because they relate directly to the government budget. Open market operations, however, are transactions in government securities undertaken by the central bank to influence liquidity and interest rates in the economy. Although these operations involve government securities, they are used as a monetary policy tool and are not normally classified as fiscal policy instruments.


Step-by-Step Solution:
Step 1: Look at option B, taxation. Changing tax rates, introducing new taxes or removing existing ones are classic fiscal policy actions that affect disposable income, consumption and investment.Step 2: Look at option C, public borrowing. When the government borrows by issuing securities, it finances its deficit, which is a fiscal operation.Step 3: Look at option D, public expenditure. Decisions about how much to spend on infrastructure, welfare and public services are central to fiscal policy.Step 4: Look at option A, open market operations. These are buying and selling of government securities in the open market by the central bank, aimed at controlling liquidity and short term interest rates. This is a key monetary policy instrument, not a fiscal tool.


Verification / Alternative check:
You can quickly verify by asking which institution primarily uses each instrument. Taxation, borrowing and expenditure decisions are made in the budget by the government and approved by Parliament. Open market operations are executed by the central bank as part of its daily money market management. This institutional separation confirms that open market operations belong to monetary policy.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Option B is wrong as an answer because taxation is an obvious fiscal policy instrument. Option C is wrong because public borrowing is part of how the government finances its fiscal deficit. Option D is wrong because public expenditure is central to fiscal policy and is used to influence growth, employment and distribution.


Common Pitfalls:
One common source of confusion is that open market operations involve government securities, which may tempt candidates to treat them as fiscal. However, it is not the issuance of those securities but their purchase and sale by the central bank that matters for monetary policy. Another pitfall is to think broadly that anything involving money is automatically fiscal; careful attention to the role of specific institutions helps avoid such mistakes.


Final Answer:
The item that is not an instrument of fiscal policy is Open market operations in government securities.

More Questions from Indian Economy

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion