Difficulty: Medium
Correct Answer: Rs. 10664.15
Explanation:
Introduction / Context:
This partnership problem introduces the concept of a working partner who receives a fixed percentage of the profit as a managing commission before the remaining profit is divided proportionally to capital investments. Munna is a sleeping partner and Chinna is the working partner. The question asks for Munna's final share after deducting Chinna's managing charge and then distributing the remaining profit in proportion to their capital contributions.
Given Data / Assumptions:
Concept / Approach:
We first compute Chinna's commission as a fixed percentage of the total profit. Subtracting this from the total gives the remaining profit that is to be shared based on capital. The ratio of capital contributions is obtained by simplifying 1,40,000 : 80,000. We then apply this ratio to the remaining profit to find each partner's share from that portion. Munna does not receive any part of the managing commission, so his total share is only from the remaining profit.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Step 1: Total profit is Rs. 19,600.
Step 2: Chinna receives 14.5% of this as managing charge. So commission = 14.5/100 * 19600.
Step 3: Compute 19600 * 14.5/100 = 19600 * 0.145 = Rs. 2842.
Step 4: Remaining profit to be shared in capital ratio is 19600 - 2842 = Rs. 16758.
Step 5: The capital ratio of Munna to Chinna is 140000 : 80000, which simplifies by dividing by 20000 to 7 : 4.
Step 6: Total parts in this ratio are 7 + 4 = 11 parts.
Step 7: Value of one part of the remaining profit is 16758 / 11 ≈ 1523.4545.
Step 8: Munna's share from the remaining profit is 7 * 16758 / 11 = 10664.18, which rounds to approximately Rs. 10664.15.
Step 9: Munna does not receive any share from the managing commission, so his total share remains about Rs. 10664.15.
Verification / Alternative check:
We can verify by calculating Chinna's total earnings. Chinna receives the managing charge of Rs. 2842 plus his share from the remaining profit, which is 4 * 16758 / 11 = Rs. 6093.82 approximately. Adding these, Chinna's total share is about 2842 + 6093.82 = Rs. 8935.82. Munna's share of about Rs. 10664.18 plus Chinna's share of about Rs. 8935.82 gives a total of roughly Rs. 19600, matching the given total profit with only rounding differences. This confirms the correctness of the approach and the result.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Values such as Rs. 9580.25, Rs. 10600, Rs. 11060.48 and Rs. 9800 either underestimate or overestimate Munna's share and do not maintain the correct division of the remaining profit after subtracting the managing commission. When checked against the ratio 7 : 4 and the exact remaining amount of Rs. 16758, they fail to satisfy the required proportionality and do not sum correctly with Chinna's share to the total profit of Rs. 19600.
Common Pitfalls:
Some learners forget to subtract the managing commission before applying the capital ratio, and instead distribute the entire profit based on capitals, which is incorrect. Others may miscalculate the commission percentage or round intermediate values too early. Using exact fractions up to the final step and clearly separating the commission part from the shared profit part helps avoid these issues.
Final Answer:
Munna's share in the profit is approximately Rs. 10664.15, matching option C.
Discussion & Comments