Polytropic efficiency in multistage compressors: is it constant across stages? Assess the statement: “For a well-designed multistage compressor operating at similar conditions in each stage, the polytropic efficiency can be taken as the same for all stages.”

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: True

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
Polytropic efficiency is a differential (small-step) measure that characterizes how closely a real compression process follows an isentropic path. In multistage machines designed with similar geometry, Reynolds/Mach numbers, and cooling arrangements, it is common engineering practice to assume the same polytropic efficiency in each stage for preliminary design and performance prediction.



Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Stages have comparable tip speeds, clearances, valve behavior (reciprocating) or blade aerodynamics (dynamic).
  • Intercooling restores similar inlet temperatures for each stage (nearly perfect intercooling).
  • Pressure ratios per stage are chosen to be approximately equal.


Concept / Approach:
Because polytropic efficiency is relatively insensitive to the absolute pressure level when flow regime and geometry are similar, designers often assign a single value across stages. Detailed tests may reveal small differences, but the equal-efficiency assumption is accurate enough for sizing and for estimating overall work and discharge temperatures.



Step-by-Step Solution:

Define polytropic efficiency as the ratio of ideal small-step work to actual small-step work.Note similarity: identical machine elements and operating regimes → similar losses per stage.Conclude: use a common polytropic efficiency for all stages in preliminary design.


Verification / Alternative check:
Factory test results frequently report stage efficiencies within a narrow band; averaging to a single representative polytropic efficiency yields accurate overall predictions.



Why Other Options Are Wrong:

Limiting the statement to single-acting machines or zero clearance is unnecessary; the assumption pertains to similarity, not acting mode.Declaring it false ignores widespread design practice and the basis of stage-stacking methods.



Common Pitfalls:
Confusing polytropic efficiency (a differential metric) with isentropic efficiency for the whole machine; the latter can vary more with pressure ratio distribution.



Final Answer:

True

More Questions from Compressors, Gas Dynamics and Gas Turbines

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion