Difficulty: Medium
Correct Answer: Carbon monoxide (CO)
Explanation:
Introduction / Context:
Urban air often contains a mixture of pollutants emitted by vehicles, industries and domestic sources. Different pollutants affect health in different ways and at different concentration ranges. This question asks which pollutant among sulphur dioxide, carbon monoxide, ozone in the upper atmosphere, nitrogen oxides and suspended particulate matter is considered especially serious as a direct health hazard under common exposure conditions, reinforcing understanding of the specific dangers of carbon monoxide.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Pollutants listed include gaseous substances and particulate matter.
- The focus is on direct health hazards to humans breathing urban air at ground level.
- Ozone is specified as being in the upper atmosphere, which has different effects than ground level ozone.
- Standard school level emphasis on carbon monoxide poisoning is assumed.
Concept / Approach:
While sulphur dioxide, nitrogen oxides and particulate matter can cause respiratory problems and long term health effects, carbon monoxide stands out for its acute and sometimes fatal impact at relatively low concentrations. As discussed in the previous question, carbon monoxide binds strongly to haemoglobin to form carboxyhaemoglobin, reducing the oxygen carrying capacity of blood and causing tissue hypoxia. Ozone in the upper atmosphere is actually beneficial because it protects the Earth from harmful ultraviolet radiation, so it is not a health hazard at that location. Given typical classroom treatments, carbon monoxide is highlighted as the most serious direct health hazard among these options.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Step 1: Evaluate sulphur dioxide. It is an irritating gas that can cause respiratory issues, especially in sensitive individuals, but acute poisoning at typical urban levels is less common.
Step 2: Evaluate carbon monoxide. It is colourless and odourless and can cause serious poisoning by forming carboxyhaemoglobin even at relatively low concentrations.
Step 3: Consider ozone in the upper atmosphere, which protects against ultraviolet radiation and is not inhaled by people at ground level in that form.
Step 4: Evaluate nitrogen oxides and particulate matter; they contribute to smog and long term health issues but are usually taught as less immediately deadly than carbon monoxide in basic discussions.
Step 5: Conclude that carbon monoxide is the most serious direct health hazard among the given options at typical urban exposure levels.
Verification / Alternative check:
Many educational materials on environmental pollution separate pollutants into those that cause chronic respiratory problems and those that can cause acute poisoning. Carbon monoxide appears prominently in discussions of indoor air pollution from faulty heaters and exhaust leaks, with warnings about its ability to cause death without warning. Emergency treatment protocols and safety guidelines often specifically address carbon monoxide detectors. While sulphur dioxide, nitrogen oxides and particulate matter are serious and regulated, the immediacy and severity of carbon monoxide poisoning support its identification as the most serious health hazard in this simplified comparison.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Sulphur dioxide can cause irritation and bronchoconstriction, especially in asthmatics, but its impact at normal urban concentrations is often less acutely life threatening than carbon monoxide poisoning. Ozone in the upper atmosphere is beneficial, not harmful, and so does not qualify as a health hazard in that location. Nitrogen oxides contribute to smog formation and acid rain, with significant environmental impacts, but they are not usually singled out as the most dangerous acute toxin in basic school level descriptions. Suspended particulate matter is a major long term health concern but is not the central focus of simple carbon monoxide based poisoning discussions. Therefore, these are not the best answers in the given context.
Common Pitfalls:
Students may focus on overall pollution severity or environmental damage and choose sulphur dioxide or nitrogen oxides, forgetting the acute toxicity of carbon monoxide. Another pitfall is to ignore the phrase upper atmosphere and assume all ozone is harmful, even though the depletion of stratospheric ozone is a major environmental concern for different reasons. By distinguishing acute poisoning from long term respiratory and environmental effects, learners can more accurately recognise carbon monoxide as the most serious direct health hazard here.
Final Answer:
Among the listed pollutants, the most serious direct health hazard to humans at typical exposure levels is Carbon monoxide (CO).
Discussion & Comments