Among the common allotropes of phosphorus, which solid form is the most chemically reactive under ordinary conditions?

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: White phosphorus

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
Phosphorus is a non metal that exists in several different solid forms called allotropes, such as white, red, black, and violet phosphorus. These allotropes have the same element, but different arrangements of atoms in the solid, which leads to very different physical and chemical properties. General chemistry and competitive exams often ask which allotrope is the most reactive, because this is directly connected to its structure and safety in handling.


Given Data / Assumptions:

  • We are comparing the reactivity of different solid forms of phosphorus: white, red, black, violet, and related amorphous forms.
  • All allotropes consist of phosphorus atoms but differ in how the atoms are bonded and packed in the solid.
  • Reactivity here refers mainly to how easily the allotrope reacts with oxygen and other reagents at normal temperatures.
  • Normal laboratory conditions and air exposure are assumed.


Concept / Approach:
Reactivity of an allotrope depends on factors such as bond strain, bond angles, stability of the structure, and surface area. White phosphorus is made of P4 tetrahedral molecules with significant bond angle strain, and the molecules are held together only by weak intermolecular forces. This makes white phosphorus unstable and very eager to react, especially with oxygen in air, where it can ignite spontaneously. Red, black, and violet phosphorus have more extended polymeric or layered structures that are thermodynamically more stable and therefore less reactive.


Step-by-Step Solution:
Step 1: Recall that white phosphorus consists of discrete P4 molecules with strained P–P–P bond angles of about 60 degrees. Step 2: Understand that this high strain and weak intermolecular forces make white phosphorus metastable and ready to react, especially in air. Step 3: Note that red phosphorus has a polymeric structure, where P atoms form long chains or networks with less bond angle strain and greater stability. Step 4: Recognise that black and violet phosphorus have layered structures similar to graphite, which are even more stable and less reactive. Step 5: Conclude that among the listed forms, white phosphorus is the most reactive allotrope under ordinary conditions.


Verification / Alternative check:
In practice, white phosphorus must be stored under water because it can oxidise and even catch fire in air at relatively low temperatures. It glows in the dark (chemiluminescence) due to slow oxidation, which is another sign of high reactivity. Red phosphorus, in contrast, is used safely on matchbox striking surfaces, where it reacts only when triggered by friction and heat. Black phosphorus is even more inert and is studied as a layered material. Textbooks consistently state that white phosphorus is the most reactive allotrope, confirming this choice.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Red phosphorus is less reactive than white phosphorus and does not ignite spontaneously in air. Black phosphorus is the most thermodynamically stable allotrope and is comparatively unreactive. Violet phosphorus is also more stable than white phosphorus and does not show such extreme reactivity. Amorphous forms can be reactive, but standard teaching focuses on white phosphorus as the most reactive allotrope among the named crystalline forms.


Common Pitfalls:
A common mistake is to assume that the darker allotropes like black phosphorus must be more reactive because they look less familiar, or to think that red phosphorus used in matches is the most reactive. In reality, safety data and storage requirements show that white phosphorus is far more dangerous and reactive. To remember this, associate white phosphorus with the need to store it under water and with its ability to glow and ignite in air, traits that clearly indicate very high reactivity.


Final Answer:
Among the common allotropes of phosphorus, the most reactive form is white phosphorus.

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion