In astronomy, most of the early known extrasolar planets discovered by astronomers were found to most closely resemble which planet in our own solar system in terms of size and gaseous composition?

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: Jupiter

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
Extrasolar planets, also called exoplanets, are planets that orbit stars outside our solar system. Since the 1990s, thousands of exoplanets have been discovered using techniques such as radial velocity measurements and transit observations. Many of the earliest and easiest to detect exoplanets turned out to be large gas giants, often very close to their parent stars. This question asks which planet in our own solar system these early exoplanets most resembled.


Given Data / Assumptions:

  • The question concerns most of the early known extrasolar planets, not every exoplanet ever discovered.
  • The focus is on which solar system planet they most resemble.
  • The options given are Jupiter, Neptune, Earth and Venus.
  • We assume a basic understanding of the sizes and types of planets in our solar system.


Concept / Approach:
Many of the first discovered exoplanets were what astronomers call hot Jupiters. These are gas giant planets similar in mass and size to Jupiter but often orbiting very close to their stars, leading to high surface temperatures. Because detection methods are biased towards large, massive planets that cause strong signals, most early exoplanets shared characteristics with Jupiter rather than with smaller rocky planets such as Earth or Venus. Neptune is also a gas or ice giant, but the term hot Jupiter and related detections are more widely associated with Jupiter like planets.


Step-by-Step Solution:
Step 1: Recall that Jupiter is the largest planet in our solar system and is a gas giant with a high mass and large radius. Step 2: Recognise that early exoplanet detection techniques strongly favoured massive planets, because they create larger wobbles in their host stars or deeper transits in brightness. Step 3: Understand that many of these early detections were categorised as hot Jupiters, emphasising their similarity in size and composition to Jupiter. Step 4: Compare this with Neptune, which is smaller and often used as a comparison for another class, sometimes called hot Neptunes, but these were not the majority of the earliest detections. Step 5: Note that Earth and Venus are terrestrial planets, and Earth sized exoplanets are more difficult to detect and became common in discoveries only with later, more sensitive missions. Step 6: Therefore, the best answer is that most early known exoplanets most closely resembled Jupiter.


Verification / Alternative check:
To verify this, you can consult astronomy textbooks, research articles or educational websites that discuss the history of exoplanet discovery. They typically stress that the first wave of exoplanet discoveries consisted largely of gas giants similar in mass to Jupiter, many of them in tight orbits. The frequent use of the phrase hot Jupiter in scientific and popular literature confirms that these planets were considered Jupiter like rather than Earth like.



Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Neptune is also a gas or ice giant, but the majority of early exoplanets were closer in mass and public description to Jupiter, and the widely used term hot Jupiter reflects this. Earth sized and Venus sized exoplanets are more challenging to detect and were not the dominant group in the earliest discoveries, so Earth and Venus are not correct answers.

Thus, while a variety of exoplanets have now been discovered, the early known group is best compared with Jupiter.



Common Pitfalls:
Students may confuse modern discoveries of many Earth sized exoplanets with the historical pattern of early detections. Others may think about similarity in surface conditions or habitability rather than detection bias. To avoid these pitfalls, separate the history of discovery from current catalogues and focus on what astronomers were finding in the first decades of exoplanet research.



Final Answer:
Most of the early known extrasolar planets were gas giants that most closely resembled Jupiter.

More Questions from Basic General Knowledge

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion