Difficulty: Medium
Correct Answer: Pressure difference caused by fast moving air between train and man
Explanation:
Introduction / Context:
When a fast train passes close to a person standing on a platform, the person sometimes feels as if they are being pulled towards the train. This can be dangerous and is often mentioned in safety warnings. The question asks you to identify the main physical reason for this effect. Understanding it involves applying basic fluid dynamics and Bernoulli's principle to the air flow around the moving train and the stationary environment.
Given Data / Assumptions:
Concept / Approach:
As the train moves quickly, it drags air along with it, creating a region of fast moving air in the narrow gap between the train and the person. According to Bernoulli's principle, where a fluid (including air) moves faster, its static pressure is lower compared to slower moving regions. The air on the far side of the person, away from the train, is more or less still and thus at higher pressure. This pressure difference creates a net force pushing the man towards the region of lower pressure, that is, towards the train. Gravity between the train and man is negligible, and centripetal force is not relevant because the man is not moving in a circular path.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Step 1: Recognise that a fast moving train creates strong air currents along its sides due to friction and drag.Step 2: In the narrow gap between the train and the man, the air flows rapidly in the direction of the train's motion.Step 3: Apply Bernoulli's principle, which states that in a streamline flow, increased speed of the fluid is accompanied by decreased pressure.Step 4: The air pressure in the fast moving region between the train and man is therefore lower than the relatively still air on the other side of the man.Step 5: This pressure difference results in a net force pushing the man towards the train, making him feel a pulling effect.
Verification / Alternative check:
Similar effects can be observed in other situations: two ships moving close to each other may be drawn together, and two nearby trains can experience lateral forces due to pressure differences. Aerodynamics studies show that fast moving bodies through air disturb the pressure distribution around them. Safety guidelines at stations often advise standing well behind the yellow line to reduce the effect of these air currents. These practical observations agree with the explanation based on pressure differences caused by fast moving air rather than gravitational or imaginary forces.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Gravitational attraction between the train and the man, option A, is extremely small compared to the gravitational pull of the earth and cannot account for the noticeable sideways pulling force. The idea that the effect is only an illusion, option B, ignores the real aerodynamic forces that can even cause accidents. Centripetal force, option C, is associated with circular motion and does not apply to a stationary man and a linearly moving train. Only option D, pressure difference due to fast moving air between the train and the man, correctly explains the phenomenon using Bernoulli's principle.
Common Pitfalls:
Students may attribute any unusual force to gravity out of habit, forgetting that gravity acts vertically rather than sideways in this situation. Others may think of centripetal force whenever a force towards something is mentioned, even when circular motion is absent. To avoid such mistakes, carefully consider the geometry and the actual motion involved. Remember that moving vehicles can create strong air currents and pressure differences, and Bernoulli's principle provides the correct framework to understand these effects near fast moving trains and vehicles.
Final Answer:
Pressure difference caused by fast moving air between train and man
Discussion & Comments