Overall thermal efficiency of a lumpy-coal-fired heating furnace For a suitably designed, well-operated and well-maintained furnace burning lumpy coal, the typical overall thermal efficiency may be approximately what percent?
-
A10–15
-
B25–30
-
C45–50
-
D65–70
-
E35–40
Answer
Correct Answer: 25–30
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Overall thermal efficiency for fuel-fired furnaces accounts for useful heat delivered to the load divided by the chemical energy in the fuel. For conventional lumpy-coal-fired heating furnaces (e.g., older reheat or small industrial units), stack losses, wall losses, and incomplete heat recovery limit achievable efficiency compared to modern regenerative/recuperative designs.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Fuel: lumpy coal, hand- or mechanically-fired.
- Furnace: suitably designed and properly maintained.
- Operating: reasonable draft and air-fuel control but without advanced heat recovery.
Concept / Approach:Typical literature values place plain, non-regenerative solid-fuel heating furnaces in the low-to-mid 20–30% range when averaged over a shift, because of high excess air, intermittent firing, radiation through walls/doors, and hot-flue losses. Higher values require extensive waste-heat recovery or continuous high-load operation with tight control.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Recognize realistic loss mechanisms: stack temperature, wall radiation, leakage, and incomplete heat transfer to the load.Compare ranges: 10–15% is unusually low for a sound furnace; 45–70% is characteristic of advanced recuperative/regenerative/heavy-duty units.Select the typical range: 25–30%.Verification / Alternative check:Benchmarking of traditional shop furnaces shows fuel-to-load efficiencies in the mid-20s without strong heat recovery or continuous operation at design capacity.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- 10–15: Too pessimistic for a properly designed and maintained furnace.
- 45–50, 65–70: Generally require recuperators/regenerators or modern burners with superior controls.
- 35–40: Above typical for lumpy coal without significant heat recovery.
Common Pitfalls:Confusing boiler thermal efficiency with furnace efficiency; furnaces heating solids often have lower efficiency than steam generators.
Final Answer:25–30