Collision avoidance requirement: You need a LAN technology that inherently prevents collisions on the medium while providing orderly access. Which option best satisfies this requirement?

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: Token-Ring

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
Media access control determines how multiple nodes share a LAN without interfering. Some methods allow contention (collisions may occur and are handled), while others serialize access so collisions do not occur in the first place. Choosing a collision-free method can be important for deterministic latency and legacy equipment compatibility.


Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Goal: avoid collisions on the shared medium.
  • Consider classic wired LAN technologies and access methods.
  • Deterministic token-passing is acceptable.


Concept / Approach:
Token-Ring uses a circulating token; only the station holding the token transmits. Because at most one station transmits at a time, collisions are inherently prevented. In contrast, CSMA/CD (legacy shared Ethernet) allows collisions and resolves them with backoff, while CSMA/CA (wireless) reduces—but does not entirely eliminate—collisions due to hidden nodes and timing limits. ARCnet also uses token passing, but Token-Ring is the canonical answer in common curricula.


Step-by-Step Solution:

1) Identify which protocols are contention-based (CSMA/CD, many Ethernet variants) vs. token-based.2) Token-passing implies single-transmitter at any instant → no collisions.3) Choose Token-Ring as the most recognized collision-free LAN method.


Verification / Alternative check:
Textbooks consistently categorize Token-Ring as collision-free by design. Modern switched Ethernet also avoids collisions per port, but the protocol family historically relied on CSMA/CD for shared segments.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:

CSMA/CD: collisions are part of the algorithm; they are detected, not prevented.Ethernet: historically used CSMA/CD on shared media; switched Ethernet removes collisions but is not described as a “collision avoidance method.”CSMA/CA: attempts to avoid collisions but cannot guarantee none on a shared wireless medium.ARCnet: also token-based, but far less common; the best single answer in standard curricula is Token-Ring.


Common Pitfalls:
Assuming modern Ethernet never collides due to switches, which is true per-port but not the same as a token-based MAC that enforces serialized access.


Final Answer:
Token-Ring.

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion