Noise immunity vs. power: Evaluate the statement: “Power dissipation is a measure of a circuit’s noise immunity.”
-
AIncorrect
-
BCorrect
-
CCorrect only for ECL
-
DCorrect only above 10 mW/gate
-
E
Answer
Correct Answer: Incorrect
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Noise immunity quantifies how robustly a logic circuit tolerates unwanted disturbances on its inputs and power rails. Power dissipation, by contrast, measures energy consumption. While some high-power families may incidentally enjoy larger noise margins, power alone is not the metric for immunity. This question separates these concepts.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Noise immunity is commonly evaluated using input noise margins: NMH = VOH(min) − VIH(min) and NML = VIL(max) − VOL(max).
- Power dissipation depends on static leakage and dynamic switching losses under specified load and frequency.
- Different logic families show varied relationships between power and margins.
Concept / Approach:Noise immunity derives from logic-level thresholds and output drive guarantees, not directly from watts consumed. Designers compare VOH/VOL against VIH/VIL to calculate noise margins. Although higher supply voltages or stronger drivers (which may increase power) can improve margins, the definitive measure remains the margin equations, not power itself.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Identify correct measures: NMH and NML quantify immunity.Note that power is orthogonal: it reflects efficiency, thermal load, and battery life.Conclude that stating “power dissipation is a measure of noise immunity” is incorrect.Verification / Alternative check:Datasheets list noise margins and logic thresholds in separate tables from power characteristics, demonstrating that they are distinct specifications evaluated differently.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Correct/ECL-only/thresholded claims: These confuse correlation with causation; immunity is not measured in watts.Common Pitfalls:Assuming a hotter, higher-power device is automatically more robust; always compute noise margins using the specified voltage levels and loads.
Final Answer:Incorrect