Diagnosing an open (failed) capacitor using an analog ohmmeter: what needle behavior should you expect?
-
AStay on zero (dead short)
-
BStay on infinity (open circuit)
-
CMove from zero to infinity (charge then settle open)
-
DMove from infinity to zero (charge then short)
Answer
Correct Answer: Stay on infinity (open circuit)
Explanation
Introduction:Using an analog ohmmeter to assess capacitors relies on observing transient charging behavior. A healthy capacitor briefly conducts as it charges from the meter's internal battery, then its indicated resistance rises. An open capacitor behaves differently. This question targets practical troubleshooting skills.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Analog ohmmeter with internal DC source.
- Capacitor disconnected from circuit and discharged before testing.
- Looking for qualitative needle movement.
Concept / Approach:A good capacitor initially appears as a low resistance (charging current flows) and then the resistance increases as the capacitor voltage builds, approaching infinity when fully charged. An open capacitor has a broken internal connection, so no charging current flows and the meter reads open circuit constantly.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Connect leads with correct polarity (for electrolytics) or either way (for nonpolarized).Observe needle: a good capacitor moves from low resistance toward high resistance over a second or two.For an open capacitor, no movement occurs; the needle remains at infinity because current cannot flow.Verification / Alternative check:Cross-check with a capacitance meter or ESR meter. An open capacitor will show extremely low capacitance (near zero) and often infinite ESR.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Stay on zero: Indicates a shorted capacitor, not open.
- Move from zero to infinity: Describes a healthy capacitor's transient response.
- Move from infinity to zero: Suggests a short developing; not open.
Common Pitfalls:Failing to discharge the capacitor before testing, misinterpreting the analog scale, or testing in-circuit where parallel paths can mask the result.
Final Answer:Stay on infinity (open circuit).