T-cell development — If MHC class II is not expressed in the thymus, which function would NOT be reduced (i.e., is the exception)?

Difficulty: Medium

Correct Answer: CD8 T cell-mediated cytotoxicity

Explanation:


Introduction:
T-cell positive selection in the thymus depends on cortical epithelial cell expression of MHC molecules. Class II MHC is required to select CD4 T cells, while class I MHC is needed for CD8 T cells. This question asks which immune function would NOT be reduced if thymic MHC class II were absent.


Given Data / Assumptions:

  • MHC class II expression in thymus is essential for generating CD4 T cells.
  • CD4 T cells provide help to B cells (class switching to IgG) and activate macrophages (Th1) for intracellular/vesicular pathogens.
  • CD8 T cells are selected on MHC class I, not class II.
  • Alternative complement activation is innate and MHC-independent.


Concept / Approach:
Predict consequences of lacking CD4 T cells: decreased Th-dependent macrophage activation and impaired T-dependent antibody responses (e.g., IgG). Identify which listed function relies on CD8 or innate pathways and therefore would not necessarily be reduced.


Step-by-Step Solution:

1) Remove MHC II in thymus → no positive selection for CD4 → severe CD4 lymphopenia.2) With low CD4, expect reduced Th1-mediated macrophage activation and reduced T-dependent isotype switching (IgG).3) CD8 cytotoxicity depends on MHC I selection → remains relatively intact.4) Complement alternative pathway is innate → not directly affected by thymic MHC II absence.


Verification / Alternative check:
Patients with bare lymphocyte syndrome type II (MHC II deficiency) show markedly decreased CD4 counts and impaired humoral responses, while CD8 T cells can be near normal since MHC I is preserved.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:

a) Typically not reduced by lack of MHC II; however, among adaptive options, CD8 function most clearly persists.c) Requires Th1 CD4 help; reduced.d) Requires T-cell help for class switching; reduced.e) A CD4-mediated response; reduced.


Common Pitfalls:
Assuming all T-cell functions decline; failing to separate CD4-dependent functions from CD8-dependent or innate pathways.


Final Answer:
CD8 T cell-mediated cytotoxicity would NOT be reduced.

More Questions from Disease Associated with Immune System

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion