Track condition quantification: If a is the number of peaks > 10 mm of unevenness per km, b is peaks > 6 mm of gauge variation per km, and c is peaks > 2 mm twist per metre, what is the Composite Current Recording Index (Ic) recommended by Northern Railway?
-
AIc = 20 - a - b - c/4
-
BIc = 40 - a - b - c/4
-
CIc = 30 - a - b - c/4
-
DIc = 10 - a - b - c/4
-
EIc = 50 - a - b - c/4
Answer
Correct Answer: Ic = 30 - a - b - c/4
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Track-recording cars measure defects in longitudinal level (unevenness), gauge variation, and twist. A composite index condenses these readings into a single value for maintenance prioritization. The Northern Railway formula is a commonly cited benchmark in Indian practice.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- a = average peaks of unevenness > 10 mm per km.
- b = average peaks of gauge variation > 6 mm per km.
- c = average peaks of twist > 2 mm per metre.
Concept / Approach:The composite index penalizes the Ic value for higher counts of defects. Unevenness and gauge peaks have full weight; twist is down-weighted (divided by 4) recognizing its different scaling/occurrence frequency.
Step-by-Step Solution:Adopt the recommended form Ic = 30 - a - b - c/4.Interpretation: higher a, b, or c reduces Ic, signaling worse track condition.Plan maintenance when Ic drops below specified thresholds.
Verification / Alternative check:Try sample values: if a = 10, b = 6, c = 8, then Ic = 30 - 10 - 6 - 2 = 12, indicating significant defects and need for attention.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- 10, 20, or 40 as the constant base do not match the Northern Railway guidance for the stated thresholds.
- 50 is not standard for this formulation.
Common Pitfalls:
- Mixing thresholds from different administrations or older manuals.
- Forgetting to divide twist peaks by 4.
Final Answer:Ic = 30 - a - b - c/4.