Difficulty: Medium
Correct Answer: Because HTML5 is not based on SGML and uses a single simple doctype with built in parsing rules in browsers
Explanation:
Introduction / Context:
Earlier versions of HTML were formally defined as applications of SGML, the Standard Generalized Markup Language. They relied on external Document Type Definition files to specify valid document structure. HTML5 changed this approach. It simplified the doctype declaration and defined its own parsing rules directly in the specification. This question asks why HTML5 does not require a traditional DTD in the same way as older HTML standards.
Given Data / Assumptions:
Concept / Approach:
HTML5 is defined as its own markup language with detailed parsing algorithms that browsers must follow. It is no longer specified as an SGML application and therefore does not need external DTD files to understand document structure. The doctype in HTML5 mainly triggers standards mode in browsers rather than pointing to an external DTD file for validation. As a result, the correct option must refer to the fact that HTML5 is not SGML based and that browsers use built in rules instead of DTDs.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Step 1 Recall that older HTML doctypes were long and referenced external DTDs hosted by standards organizations.
Step 2 Note that HTML5 replaced these with a single minimal declaration: <!DOCTYPE html>.
Step 3 Understand that HTML5 parsing behavior and permitted elements are defined directly in the specification, and browsers follow these rules without consulting an external DTD file.
Step 4 Choose the option that states that HTML5 is not based on SGML and uses a single simple doctype with built in parsing rules.
Verification / Alternative check:
Reading the HTML5 specification shows that it includes complete algorithms for tokenizing and parsing HTML, including how to handle invalid markup. The specification does not reference SGML DTDs. Additionally, browser documentation explains that the HTML5 doctype is used mainly to enable standards mode rendering. There is no requirement for browsers to fetch or interpret external DTD files for HTML5 documents, which confirms the given explanation.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
The claim that HTML5 documents never need validation is incorrect, because validation is still useful even though it is no longer based on SGML DTDs. Saying that HTML5 is a programming language that replaces markup is wrong; HTML5 is still a markup language. The idea that HTML5 requires one DTD per browser vendor is the opposite of the goal of standardization. The statement that HTML5 supports only XML syntax and no tags is also false; HTML5 supports both classic HTML syntax and XHTML style syntax with tags.
Common Pitfalls:
Developers sometimes think that the short doctype means validation is no longer important, which can lead to sloppy markup. Another pitfall is confusing HTML5 with XHTML and assuming strict XML rules always apply. Understanding that HTML5 uses its own well defined parsing rules and does not rely on external SGML DTDs helps clarify the role of the doctype.
Final Answer:
HTML5 does not require a traditional DTD because HTML5 is not based on SGML and uses a single simple doctype with built in parsing rules in browsers.
Discussion & Comments