Difficulty: Easy
Correct Answer: either (b) or (c)
Explanation:
Introduction / Context:
For plane pin-jointed trusses, the simple test m = 2j − 3 helps classify whether a frame is statically determinate (perfect), unstable (deficient), or redundant (excess). This criterion is widely used in structural analysis as a quick screening before detailed calculations.
Given Data / Assumptions:
Concept / Approach:
A simple (perfect) truss satisfies m = 2j − 3. If m < 2j − 3, the truss is deficient in members (mechanism/unstable). If m > 2j − 3, it is redundant and therefore imperfect from a purely statical-determinacy standpoint.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Perfect frame condition: m = 2j − 3.Deficient (unstable): m < 2j − 3.Redundant (statically indeterminate): m > 2j − 3.Imperfect = not perfect ⇒ m ≠ 2j − 3 ⇒ either less than or greater than 2j − 3.
Verification / Alternative check:
Classical examples: A triangular frame (j = 3) with m = 3 is perfect (3 = 2*3 − 3). Removing one member (m = 2) makes it a mechanism (deficient). Adding an extra member (m = 4) introduces redundancy (excess). Both non-equal cases are imperfect.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Common Pitfalls:
Final Answer:
either (b) or (c)
Discussion & Comments