Difficulty: Medium
Correct Answer: 36 years, 9 years
Explanation:
Introduction / Context:This mixes a present sum condition with a past product condition. The structure simplifies after factoring the past product equation.
Given Data / Assumptions:
Concept / Approach:Factor the past equation by taking (f − 5) common. This yields two possible cases; reject the infeasible one and use the sum to find both ages.
Step-by-Step Solution:
(f − 5)(s − 5) = 4(f − 5)(f − 5)[(s − 5) − 4] = 0 ⇒ (f − 5)(s − 9) = 0Either f = 5 (impossible for a father) or s = 9Thus s = 9 ⇒ f = 45 − 9 = 36Verification / Alternative check:
Five years ago: f = 31, s = 4 ⇒ product = 124; 4(f − 5) = 4×31 = 124 ✓Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Common Pitfalls:Missing the factorization shortcut; choosing f = 5 despite being unrealistic; or misapplying the 5-year shift to only one age.
Final Answer:36 years, 9 years
Discussion & Comments