In the following sentence on error spotting, identify the part that contains a grammatical or usage error. The food basket contained a dark chocolate, an eclair and a pastry neatly wrapped in foil paper.

Difficulty: Medium

Correct Answer: B

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
This error spotting question tests knowledge of article use and countable versus uncountable nouns in English. The sentence describes items in a food basket, and the examinee must identify which part contains a usage error. In such questions, the grammar may be mostly correct, but a subtle issue such as an incorrect article or wrong noun form makes one part unacceptable.


Given Data / Assumptions:
• The full sentence reads: The food basket contained a dark chocolate, an eclair and a pastry neatly wrapped in foil paper.• Part A: The food basket contained.• Part B: a dark chocolate, an eclair and a pastry.• Part C: neatly wrapped in foil paper.• The phrase a dark chocolate is the key area of concern.


Concept / Approach:
In English, chocolate can be both countable and uncountable. When referring to a specific piece, we usually say a bar of dark chocolate or a piece of dark chocolate, not a dark chocolate by itself, unless chocolate refers to a specific product or sweet that is commonly counted that way. In standard exam English, a dark chocolate without a noun such as bar or piece is considered incorrect. An eclair and a pastry are fine because these are individual items that are commonly counted with a. Therefore, the error is in part B, where the article a is used directly with dark chocolate.


Step-by-Step Solution:
Step 1: Read the entire sentence and look for unnatural or unidiomatic phrases.Step 2: Note that The food basket contained is a correct opening clause.Step 3: Focus on a dark chocolate, an eclair and a pastry. While an eclair and a pastry are acceptable, a dark chocolate should be replaced by a bar of dark chocolate or simply dark chocolate, depending on whether we are counting pieces or describing a type.Step 4: Check neatly wrapped in foil paper. Although some speakers might simply say wrapped in foil, the phrase is understandable and not typically the primary error in exam keys.Step 5: Conclude that part B contains the main usage error because of the incorrect article and noun combination.


Verification / Alternative check:
Consider other combinations: The food basket contained dark chocolate, an eclair and a pastry neatly wrapped in foil. This version sounds more natural. Alternatively, The food basket contained a bar of dark chocolate, an eclair and a pastry is even clearer. Both confirm that the word chocolate needs either a quantifying noun like bar or piece, or should be used without a when treated as an uncountable substance. This supports the conclusion that part B is incorrect as framed in the question.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Option a: The food basket contained is grammatically correct and sets up the list of items properly.Option c: neatly wrapped in foil paper is acceptable in many exam contexts. While some stylists might prefer foil instead of foil paper, this is not usually treated as a clear grammatical error in such questions.Option d: No error is incorrect, because the use of a dark chocolate is not standard as presented.


Common Pitfalls:
Many learners focus only on obvious grammatical markers like tense and subject verb agreement and overlook subtler lexical or collocation errors. It is also easy to accept a dark chocolate because we sometimes see chocolates used as a plural count noun in casual speech, but the pattern usually requires a piece of chocolate or a chocolate bar when precision is required. In exams, you should pay close attention to how food items and portions are normally expressed in good written English.


Final Answer:
The flawed phrase a dark chocolate appears in part B, which should be rephrased to use a bar of dark chocolate or similar wording. Correct answer: B.

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion