Difficulty: Medium
Correct Answer: Marginal
Explanation:
Introduction / Context:
This inference question is based on a short literary description from the novel "Pride and Prejudice". The passage explains that Elizabeth Bennett lives in rural 18th century England and that her family property is entailed to the nearest male heir. In such a system, women cannot inherit the main estate. You are asked to choose the word that best describes her social and economic position under these conditions.
Given Data / Assumptions:
Concept / Approach:
In this historical context, women had limited legal rights to property and were often dependent on male relatives. A woman whose family estate is entailed to a male heir has a precarious position: she belongs to the family but has little control over property or long term financial security. The key idea is that she is on the margins of economic power despite her social background. The best descriptive word should capture her vulnerable, secondary, or peripheral status rather than suggesting she is wholly irrelevant or entirely outside the system.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Step 1: Consider "Marginal". This term suggests being on the edge or periphery of power or importance, not at the centre.
Step 2: Consider "Immaterial". This term means irrelevant or not significant to a matter.
Step 3: Consider "Unrelated". This term implies no relation at all, which clearly is not true, since Elizabeth is a daughter in the family that owns the estate.
Step 4: Consider "Extraneous". This term suggests something that is external or coming from outside, not belonging naturally.
Step 5: Given that Elizabeth is central to the family but blocked from property rights, her status is not unrelated or extraneous; rather, she is pushed to the edges of inheritance and power.
Step 6: Therefore "Marginal" is the best word to describe her position in such a patriarchal inheritance structure.
Verification / Alternative check:
Think about what being "marginal" means in socio economic terms. A marginal member of society has some recognition but limited power or security. Elizabeth belongs to a respectable family but has little direct claim over property and must rely on marriage for stability. "Immaterial" would wrongly suggest that her existence or concerns do not matter at all to the story or society, which is clearly not true, as the novel focuses heavily on women lives and struggles. "Extraneous" and "unrelated" contradict the facts, since she is a key family member. Hence, "marginal" aligns with the historical and narrative context.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
"Immaterial" is wrong because Elizabeth concerns about property and marriage are central to the plot and to the depiction of women issues at the time. They are not irrelevant. "Unrelated" is factually incorrect, as she is directly related to the property owning family. "Extraneous" implies she does not belong or is an outsider, which again does not describe a daughter of the house. Only "marginal" captures the idea of being pushed to the edge of power and inheritance while still belonging to the social group that controls property.
Common Pitfalls:
Some candidates may confuse "immaterial" with "lacking material property" and assume that it refers to not owning assets. However, in academic and legal language, "immaterial" means irrelevant to a case, not lacking materials. Others may choose "extraneous" because it sounds formal, but that word is closer to "foreign" or "not belonging". To avoid these pitfalls, always recall the precise meanings of such adjectives and test them directly against the context provided in the passage.
Final Answer:
The position of young Elizabeth Bennett in that social and legal framework is best described as marginal.
Discussion & Comments