Assertion–Reason: A transistor needs a continuous base drive for conduction, whereas a thyristor (SCR) requires only a gate pulse because of latching. The reason given is “Transistors find widespread use in power electronics.” Evaluate.

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: Both A and R correct but R is not correct explanation of A

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
Understanding control requirements: BJTs and MOSFETs are controlled devices needing continuous drive (base or gate) to remain on, while thyristors are latching devices that remain on after a brief gate pulse until current falls below holding current. This is foundational in power electronics control strategies.



Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Assertion (A): Transistor requires continuous base (or sustained gate for MOSFET) drive; SCR needs a trigger pulse only.
  • Reason (R): “Transistors are widely used in power electronics.”
  • We evaluate truthfulness and explanatory linkage.


Concept / Approach:

Latching behavior of SCRs arises from regenerative feedback inside the pnpn structure; once on, it remains on as long as anode current exceeds the holding current. Transistors lack this latch and require continuous drive. The “widespread use” statement is true but does not explain the latching mechanism or drive requirement difference.



Step-by-Step Evaluation:

Check A: True—continuous drive vs latching pulse.Check R: True—transistors are indeed widely used.Causality: R does not explain why SCR needs only a pulse; explanation should reference latching/holding current, not popularity.


Verification / Alternative check:

Standard SCR theory: once turned on, device conducts until current extinction; references emphasize holding and latching currents, unrelated to transistor adoption rate.



Why Other Options Are Wrong:

  • “R explains A”: incorrect linkage.
  • “R wrong” or “A wrong”: each statement is factually correct.


Common Pitfalls:

  • Confusing MOSFET's gate charge (low static drive power) with zero drive—MOSFET still needs Vgs maintained.
  • Equating market usage with device physics.


Final Answer:

Both A and R correct but R is not correct explanation of A

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion