For a fibrous filter where multiple capture mechanisms act simultaneously, the overall single-pass collection efficiency η_total is best expressed as which combination of the individual efficiencies by impaction (ηimp), interception (ηint), and diffusion (ηdif)?

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: 1 - (1 - ηimp)(1 - ηint)( 1 - ηdif)

Explanation:


Introduction:
When impaction, interception, and diffusion act in parallel on a filter element, the correct way to combine their contributions is crucial for predicting overall filter performance. Each mechanism removes a fraction of the particles that survive the others, leading to a multiplicative survival relationship rather than a simple sum of efficiencies.


Given Data / Assumptions:

  • ηimp, ηint, ηdif are single-pass removal fractions for each independent mechanism.
  • Mechanisms act concurrently and independently on the same flow element.
  • Re-entrainment is neglected for this expression.


Concept / Approach:
Let survival fractions be S_imp = (1 - ηimp), S_int = (1 - ηint), and S_dif = (1 - ηdif). If mechanisms are independent, the total survival is S_total = S_imp * S_int * S_dif. Therefore, overall efficiency is η_total = 1 - S_total = 1 - (1 - ηimp)(1 - ηint)(1 - ηdif). This avoids double counting and stays bounded between 0 and 1 even when individual efficiencies are high.


Step-by-Step Solution:

1) Define survival for each mechanism.2) Multiply survivals to get combined survival.3) Convert back to efficiency by η_total = 1 - S_total.4) Compare to options to select the correct multiplicative form.5) Confirm dimensional consistency (dimensionless fractions).


Verification / Alternative check:
Monte Carlo particle tracking and experimental filtration data support multiplicative survival over additive efficiencies when mechanisms are independent, especially at moderate efficiencies.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:

  • 1 - ηimpηintηdif: Overestimates efficiency and mishandles independence.
  • 1 - (ηimpηint/ηdif): Dimensionally inconsistent and not physically meaningful.
  • None of the above: Incorrect because the standard relationship is listed.


Common Pitfalls:
Summing efficiencies directly can produce η_total > 1, which is impossible. Always combine via survival fractions when mechanisms act in parallel.


Final Answer:
1 - (1 - ηimp)(1 - ηint)( 1 - ηdif)

More Questions from Sterilization

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion