Difficulty: Medium
Correct Answer: It will cause the officially measured GDP to be understated relative to the true level of production.
Explanation:
Introduction / Context:
In every country there are economic activities that are not fully reported to tax authorities or statistical agencies. These activities form what is often called the underground economy, shadow economy, or informal sector. Understanding how this hidden production affects measured gross domestic product is important for interpreting economic data correctly. This question tests whether you know that unreported output leads to an official GDP figure that is lower than the economy's true productive capacity.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- There is a significant underground economy where income and production are not fully reported.
- Official GDP statistics are based on reported data collected by government agencies.
- The question asks about the direction of bias in the officially measured GDP due to unreported activities.
- We assume that underground activities are productive, not simply illegal transfers.
Concept / Approach:
Gross domestic product aims to measure the market value of all final goods and services produced within a country during a given period. However, statistical agencies rely on surveys, tax records, and business reports. When people or firms deliberately underreport their sales or income to avoid taxes or regulations, the corresponding production is missing from official records. As a result, the recorded GDP is lower than the actual value of goods and services produced. The larger the underground economy, the bigger the gap between true GDP and measured GDP. This means measured GDP is understated rather than overstated.
Step by Step Solution:
Step 1: Recognise that underground economic activities are real production but are not fully captured in official data.
Step 2: Understand that GDP statistics are constructed from reported data, so unreported output is simply missing.
Step 3: If real production is higher than reported production, the official GDP number will be less than the true GDP.
Step 4: Option D states that officially measured GDP will be understated relative to the true level of production, which matches this reasoning.
Step 5: Options A, B, and C suggest overstatement or only price index effects, which do not accurately describe the main impact of a large underground economy on measured GDP.
Verification / Alternative check:
Consider a simple example. Suppose the true value of final output in an economy is 100 units of currency, but 20 percent of that activity is conducted in cash and not reported to tax authorities or statistical agencies. The official data will only capture 80 units. Statistical agencies may make some adjustments or estimates, but if underground activity is very large and difficult to measure, there will still be a gap. This shows that the official GDP understates actual production. Similarly, cross country comparisons can be misleading if one country has a larger underground sector than another, even though their official GDP per capita looks similar.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Option A is wrong because it suggests that GDP is overstated, which would require counting non existent production, not missing real production.
Option B is wrong because it focuses only on the GDP price index and suggests underestimation there, but the main effect of unreported real activity is on the quantity side of GDP, not on the price index.
Option C is wrong for similar reasons, as it refers to the price index being overstated rather than the real output being understated.
Common Pitfalls:
Students sometimes confuse underground economic activity with purely illegal activities that might be conceptually excluded from GDP. However, many underground transactions involve legal goods and services that are simply not reported for tax reasons. Another pitfall is to think that if people evade tax, the government might overestimate output to compensate, which is not the usual case. In examinations, always remember that unreported productive activity typically leads to measured GDP being lower than the true level of output.
Final Answer:
It will cause the officially measured GDP to be understated relative to the true level of production.
Discussion & Comments