I-type statements can't be combined no conclusion follow by combined But II and III make a complementary I-E pair, Hence either I or III follows.
All sofas are beds + All beds are mats = A + A = A = All sofas are mats ? conversion ? Some mats are sofas (I). Hence I follows. All tables are sofas + All sofas are beds = A + A = A = All tables are beds ? conversion ? Some beds are tables(I). Hence II follows. All tables are beds + All beds are mats = A + A = A = All tables are mats ? conversion ? Some mats are tables (I). Hence III follows.
All flowers are trees + All trees are jungles = A + A = A = All flowers are jungles ? conversion ? Some jungles are flowers Hence III follows. All trees are jungle + No jungle is hill = A + E = E = No tree is hill. Hence III follows. All flowers are trees + No tree is hill. Hence II follows. All flowers are trees + No tree is hill = A + E = E = No flower is hill. Hence I follows.
Some buses are trucks + Some trucks are boats = I + I = No conclusion Hence II and consequently do not follow Some trucks are boats + No boat is jeep = I + E = O = Some trucks are not jeeps. Hence III does not follow.
All pins are bags (A) ? conversion ? Some bags are pins (I). All needles are bags + Some bags are pins = A + I = No conclusion Hence I and III do not follow by combination. However, they from an complementary E-I pair, either I or III follows. Again, All chalks are bags + conversion of all needles are bags = A + I = No conclusion Hence II do not follow.
All buckets are tubs(A) ? conversion ? Some tubs are buckets (I) Hence II does not follow. All buckets are tubs + All tubs are drums A + A = A = All buckets are drums ? conversion ? Some drums are buckets + All buckets are drums = A + A + I + = Some drums are pots(I). Hence II follows.
Some trees are houses + All houses are wheels = I + A = I = Some trees are wheels ? (I) conversion ? Some wheels are trees (I). Hence I follows. All flowers are tree ? (A) conversion ? Some trees are flowers (I). Hence II follows. But II and III can't, be combined as they are I -type statements Hence III does not follow.
All windows are doors + All doors are boats = A + A = A = All windows are boats. Hence I follows. All buildings are doors + All doors are boats = A + A = A = All buildings are boats. Hence II follows. All doors are boats (A) ? conversion ? Some boats are doors(I). Hence III follows.
Some mirrors are pens + No pen is paper = 1 + E = O* = Some mirrors are not papers Hence III does not follow. All buildings are mirrors + Some mirrors are pens = A + I = No conclusion Hence II and consequently I do not follow.
Some books are trees + All tress are roads = I + A = I = Some books are roads (I) Hence II follows. Some books are trees + All roads are wheels = I + A = I = Some books are wheels ? conversion ? Some wheels are books (I) Hence I follows. All trees are roads + All roads are wheels = A + A = A = All trees are wheels ? conversion ? Some wheels are trees (I) Hence III follows.
All stones are rivers + All rivers are cars = A + A = A = All stones are cars ? conversion ? Some cars are stones (I) Hence II follows. All rivers are cars + Some cars are trains = I + A = No conclusion Hence II and consequently I do not follow.
Comments
There are no comments.Copyright ©CuriousTab. All rights reserved.