Difficulty: Medium
Correct Answer: All of the above
Explanation:
Introduction / Context:
Many plants show alternation of generations, a life cycle that alternates between a diploid sporophyte and a haploid gametophyte. In most vascular plants, such as ferns, gymnosperms, and angiosperms, the sporophyte is the dominant generation. This question asks which combined statement best contrasts sporophytes and gametophytes in terms of chromosome number, vascular tissue presence, and relative size in typical vascular plants.
Given Data / Assumptions:
Concept / Approach:
In vascular plants, the sporophyte is the conspicuous plant body with roots, stems, and leaves. It is diploid and has well developed vascular tissue for transport of water and nutrients. The gametophyte is generally reduced in size, often microscopic in seed plants, and lacks extensive vascular tissue. For example, in flowering plants, the pollen grain and embryo sac are highly reduced gametophytes. Therefore, the correct contrasting description must combine diploid versus haploid ploidy, vascular versus nonvascular nature, and larger versus smaller size in typical vascular plant life cycles.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Step 1: Recall that sporophytes develop from fertilized eggs (zygotes) and therefore contain a full diploid set of chromosomes.
Step 2: Gametophytes develop from spores and are haploid, containing a single set of chromosomes because they arise after meiosis.
Step 3: Recognize that in vascular plants, sporophytes possess vascular tissue (xylem and phloem) for conduction of water and nutrients.
Step 4: Gametophytes of vascular plants are usually small, short lived, and lack the extensive vascular system seen in sporophytes.
Step 5: Compare each statement and observe that A, B, and C are all consistent with typical vascular plant biology, so the combined option All of the above is the most accurate choice.
Verification / Alternative check:
You can verify these relationships by examining examples. In ferns, the leafy plant is the diploid sporophyte with vascular tissue, while the heart shaped prothallus is the small haploid gametophyte lacking large vascular structures. In angiosperms, the large tree or herb is the sporophyte, whereas the male gametophyte is the pollen grain and the female gametophyte is the embryo sac, both tiny and nonvascular. These examples confirm that sporophytes are diploid, vascular, and larger, while gametophytes are haploid, nonvascular, and much smaller.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Option A (Sporophytes are diploid, whereas gametophytes are haploid.): This is correct but incomplete because it ignores vascular tissue and size differences that are also characteristic in vascular plants.
Option B (Sporophytes are vascular, whereas gametophytes are nonvascular.): This captures a structural contrast but does not mention ploidy or the typical dominance in size.
Option C (Sporophytes are larger than gametophytes.): This is also correct in most vascular plants but again only covers one aspect. Since all three statements are true together, the best answer is the combined option.
Common Pitfalls:
A common mistake is to generalize from bryophytes, where the gametophyte is dominant, which can confuse students about which generation is larger. Another pitfall is to focus only on ploidy and forget structural aspects such as vascular tissue development. Learners may also misinterpret the question as asking which single statement is true rather than noticing that multiple correct statements are grouped into an option that says All of the above.
Final Answer:
In typical vascular plants, sporophytes are diploid, vascular, and larger, whereas gametophytes are haploid, nonvascular, and smaller, so the best choice is All of the above.
Discussion & Comments