Introduction / Context:
This is a conceptual time-and-work puzzle about planning and adjusting workforce. The contractor initially underestimates the number of workers needed and later doubles the workforce to avoid a large delay. You have to determine what fraction of the total work had been finished before the adjustment, expressed as a percentage.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Scheduled completion time for the road = S (unknown) days.
- Initial number of workers = N (unknown).
- At some checkpoint, the contractor realises the work would be delayed by three-fourths of S (that is, total time would become S + 3S/4 = 7S/4) if he keeps N workers.
- He then doubles the workforce to 2N and finishes exactly in S days from the start.
- We assume constant work rate per worker and no other interruptions.
Concept / Approach:
The total quantity of work is fixed. We express it in terms of the original workforce N and the time that would have been needed without any change (7S/4). We then equate that with the actual scenario where the contractor works with N workers for some time and 2N workers for the remaining time but completes in S days. That gives us the time of switching and the fraction of work done by that moment.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Let total work = W units.
Original workforce = N workers, each with unit rate per worker.
If no change is made, total time needed at rate N is 7S/4 days.
So W = N * (7S / 4).
In reality, the contractor uses N workers for t days and then 2N workers for S - t days, finishing in S days.
Actual work done: W = N * t + 2N * (S - t) = N t + 2N S - 2N t = 2N S - N t.
Equate both expressions for W: N * (7S / 4) = 2N S - N t.
Divide both sides by N: 7S / 4 = 2S - t.
Solve for t: t = 2S - 7S / 4 = (8S / 4 - 7S / 4) = S / 4.
So the workforce was doubled after t = S / 4 days from the start.
Work done up to that time with N workers = N * (S / 4).
Total work W = N * (7S / 4).
Fraction of work completed = [N * (S / 4)] / [N * (7S / 4)] = 1 / 7.
Convert to percentage: 1 / 7 = 14 2/7 % approximately.
Verification / Alternative check:
Remaining work fraction after S / 4 days = 6/7 of W.
Rate after doubling = 2N, so time needed for remaining work = (6/7 W) / (2N).
Since W = N * 7S / 4, substitute: (6/7 * N * 7S / 4) / (2N) = (6S / 4) / 2 = 3S / 4.
Total time = S / 4 + 3S / 4 = S, so it matches the scheduled time.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
10% is less than 1/7 and does not satisfy the time algebra.
20% equals 1/5, again inconsistent with the equation derived from actual and projected times.
"Can not be determined" is incorrect because the system of equations yields a unique fraction independent of actual S and N values.
Common Pitfalls:
Some students misinterpret "delayed by three-fourths of the scheduled time" as a fraction of remaining time, not of S.
Others assume an explicit numerical S value without realising that it cancels out in the ratio.
The key is to treat S and N as symbols and recognise that only the fraction of work completed matters.
Final Answer:
The work completed before increasing the number of workers was 1/7 of the total work, that is 14 2/7 %.
Discussion & Comments