In plant anatomy, companion cells associated with sieve tube elements are unique to which major group of plants?

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: Angiosperms, the flowering plants with sieve tube elements and companion cells

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
In plant anatomy, the conducting tissues xylem and phloem are key for transport of water, minerals, and food. Within phloem, sieve tube elements and their associated companion cells are characteristically found in flowering plants. Exams often ask which plant group shows these specialized companion cells, because it reflects an advanced level of phloem organization and evolution. This question targets that specific concept in vascular plant anatomy.


Given Data / Assumptions:
• The question mentions companion cells, which are associated with sieve tube elements in phloem.• The options list different plant groups: bryophytes, pteridophytes, angiosperms, gymnosperms, and all vascular plants.• We use standard textbook classification of plant groups and phloem structure.• We assume typical examples such as mosses, ferns, pines, and flowering plants.


Concept / Approach:
Companion cells are small, living cells closely associated with sieve tube elements in phloem. They help in loading and unloading sugars and in maintaining the metabolic activity of the enucleate sieve tube elements. This structural combination, sieve tubes plus companion cells, is a hallmark of angiosperms, the flowering plants. Gymnosperms, pteridophytes, and bryophytes either lack this pair or have different phloem elements, such as sieve cells and albuminous cells in gymnosperms. Therefore, to answer correctly, we must recall that companion cells are unique to angiosperms.


Step-by-Step Solution:
Step 1: Recall that phloem transports organic solutes, mainly sucrose, in vascular plants.Step 2: Note that angiosperms possess sieve tube elements which are long tubes formed by end to end arrangement of sieve tube members.Step 3: Remember that each sieve tube element is closely associated with one or more companion cells derived from the same mother cell.Step 4: Recognize that gymnosperms have sieve cells and albuminous cells, not sieve tubes with companion cells, and that pteridophytes have simpler phloem.Step 5: Observe that bryophytes do not have true vascular tissues like xylem and phloem.Step 6: Conclude that only angiosperms show true companion cells with sieve tube elements.


Verification / Alternative check:
You can cross check by consulting comparative tables of xylem and phloem in different plant groups. Such tables explicitly state that sieve tube elements and companion cells are characteristic of angiosperms. Gymnosperms are described as having sieve cells plus albuminous cells, while pteridophytes have simpler sieve like elements and no typical companion cells. Bryophytes lack well developed vascular tissue altogether. This comparative evidence confirms that the unique occurrence of companion cells is in angiosperms.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Bryophytes such as mosses and liverworts are non vascular and therefore do not possess true phloem or companion cells. Pteridophytes, including ferns, have vascular tissue but their phloem lacks typical sieve tube elements and companion cells. Gymnosperms such as pines possess sieve cells and albuminous cells instead of sieve tubes and companion cells, so the association is different. All vascular plants including both gymnosperms and angiosperms is too broad and incorrect because not all of them have companion cells. Only angiosperms have the classic sieve tube and companion cell association.


Common Pitfalls:
Students sometimes assume that any vascular plant must have companion cells, which leads to incorrect choices such as all vascular plants. Another common error is mixing up albuminous cells of gymnosperms with companion cells, even though they are different both developmentally and structurally. To avoid such confusion, remember a simple rule: sieve tubes plus companion cells are a signature of angiosperms, while sieve cells plus albuminous cells belong to gymnosperms. Non vascular bryophytes do not enter this comparison at all.


Final Answer:
Companion cells associated with sieve tube elements are unique to Angiosperms, the flowering plants with sieve tube elements and companion cells.

More Questions from Biology

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion