Statement–Argument — Should colleges in India have student uniforms like schools? Arguments: I) Yes; uniforms improve ambience as all students dress decently. II) No; college students should not be regimented and should choose their attire within norms. Choose the strong argument(s).
-
Aif only argument I is strong
-
Bif only argument II is strong
-
Cif either I or II is strong
-
Dif both I and II are strong
-
ENone of these
Answer
Correct Answer: if only argument II is strong
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Universities emphasize adult learning and autonomy. Dress codes (minimum standards) may exist without mandating full uniforms.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Ambience can be addressed via codes without uniformity.
- Autonomy and self-expression are educational values in higher education.
- Uniforms can be justified in specific professional programs but not universally.
Concept / Approach:Argument I is weak: it assumes a uniform is necessary for decency; dress codes suffice. Argument II is strong: it foregrounds adult autonomy while allowing reasonable norms.
Step-by-Step Solution:
I: Overstates need for uniform → weak.II: Captures higher-ed ethos → strong.Verification / Alternative check:Most colleges operate with codes, not uniforms, except specialized institutes.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:“Either/Both” over-credit I; “Neither” ignores II’s relevance.
Common Pitfalls:Assuming school policies must extend unchanged to universities.
Final Answer:if only argument II is strong.