Which group of algae is considered the closest living relative of land plants in evolutionary terms?

Difficulty: Medium

Correct Answer: Charophytes

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
This biology question examines your understanding of plant evolution and the origin of land plants. Modern land plants did not appear suddenly; they evolved from aquatic algal ancestors. Identifying which algal group is most closely related to land plants helps you understand key evolutionary transitions such as adaptation to life on land, development of protective tissues, and alternation of generations.


Given Data / Assumptions:


    • The question asks about the closest algal relatives of land plants from the groups listed.
    • Option names refer to broad algal groups, including charophytes, chrysophytes, rhodophytes, and bacillariophytes.
    • It is assumed that you are familiar with basic characteristics of these algal groups from standard botany courses.


Concept / Approach:
Land plants, or embryophytes, are part of a larger clade of green plants that also includes certain groups of green algae. Green algae are traditionally divided into chlorophytes and charophytes. Evidence from molecular phylogenetics, cell wall composition, cell division mechanisms, and reproductive structures shows that charophyte green algae share a closer common ancestor with land plants than other algal groups. Features such as similar chlorophyll pigments, presence of cellulose rich cell walls, and details of flagella and mitosis support this relationship. Chrysophytes, rhodophytes, and bacillariophytes are photosynthetic groups but lie further away on the evolutionary tree.


Step-by-Step Solution:

Step 1: Recognise that land plants are part of the green plant lineage, which includes certain green algae. Step 2: Recall that among green algae, charophytes share many structural and biochemical features with land plants. Step 3: Note that chrysophytes, commonly called golden algae, belong to a different lineage and have distinctive pigments and storage products. Step 4: Rhodophytes, or red algae, and bacillariophytes, or diatoms, also belong to separate major algal divisions that diverged earlier in evolutionary history. Step 5: Conclude that charophytes are the closest algal relatives of land plants, so that option is correct.


Verification / Alternative check:
You can verify this answer by examining phylogenetic trees in modern botany or evolutionary biology textbooks. These trees usually group land plants with certain green algae under a clade often labelled streptophytes, which includes charophytes. Descriptions of shared traits, such as the structure of sperm cells, formation of cell plates during division, and presence of similar regulatory molecules, further confirm the close relationship between charophytes and land plants. In contrast, chrysophytes, red algae, and diatoms appear in distinct clades associated with different types of photosynthetic pigments and life cycles.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:

Chrysophytes are incorrect because they are golden brown algae belonging to a different group that does not form the direct evolutionary bridge to land plants.

Rhodophytes are incorrect because, although they are important photosynthetic organisms in marine environments, red algae do not share the specific set of derived traits that link charophytes to land plants.

Bacillariophytes are incorrect because diatoms have unique silica cell walls and belong to a separate lineage among the algae, with evolutionary relationships that are more distant from land plants.


Common Pitfalls:
A common error is to assume that any prominent algal group, especially red algae, must be close to land plants because they are multicellular and important in ecosystems. However, evolutionary closeness depends on shared derived features, not simply on ecological importance or complexity. Another mistake is to confuse chlorophytes and charophytes within green algae. While both are green algae, it is specifically the charophytes that are recognised as the closest living relatives of land plants based on multiple lines of evidence.


Final Answer:
The closest living algal relatives of land plants are the Charophytes.

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion