E is the son of A. D is the son of B. E is married to C, and C is the daughter of B. How is D related to E?

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: Brother-in-law

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:

This is a straightforward blood-relation question where you must connect in-laws and siblings. The presence of a marriage (E married to C) and their parents (A and B) naturally leads to a brother-in-law relation somewhere. Correctly placing D in the family tree relative to E is the main goal.


Given Data / Assumptions:

  • E is the son of A, so E is male.
  • D is the son of B, so D is also male.
  • E is married to C.
  • C is the daughter of B.
  • We are asked: How is D related to E?
  • We assume a simple family tree where B is the parent of both C and D (making them siblings).


Concept / Approach:

The key is to notice that C and D share the same parent B, so they are brother and sister (or at least siblings). Since E is married to C, E becomes a son-in-law of B and an in-law relative of D. More specifically, the husband of someone's sister is that person's brother-in-law. We then express D's relationship to E using this standard in-law term.


Step-by-Step Solution:

Step 1: From "E is the son of A", we know that E is male and in the younger generation. Step 2: From "D is the son of B", D is also male and in the same generation as E. Step 3: E is married to C. This marriage connects E to B's family as a son-in-law. Step 4: From "C is B's daughter", C is a child of B. Combined with "D is the son of B", this means C and D are siblings. Step 5: If C and D are siblings and E is married to C, then from D's perspective, E is the husband of his sister. Step 6: The husband of one's sister is called a brother-in-law. Therefore, D is E's brother-in-law, and E is also D's brother-in-law. The relationship is symmetric in this case.


Verification / Alternative check:

Imagine B has two children: C (daughter) and D (son). C marries E. In that scenario, any family would naturally describe E as D's brother-in-law and D as E's brother-in-law. There is no other common English kinship term that fits better. This confirms our reasoning.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:

D cannot be E's real brother, because they have different parents (A for E and B for D).

D is not E's uncle or father-in-law; those roles would involve a generational difference, whereas D and E are in the same generation and connected by a sibling's marriage.


Common Pitfalls:

Sometimes candidates try to connect everyone by blood and forget that marriage can introduce in-law relationships. Recognizing that C and D are siblings and that E's link to D is purely through marriage is crucial. When you see "son of B" and "daughter of B" alongside "married to", immediately think of brother-in-law or sister-in-law possibilities.


Final Answer:

D is related to E as his brother-in-law.

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion