Combined non-Newtonian behavior — A fluid whose viscosity increases with increasing stirrer speed (shear rate) and also increases with mixing time under constant shear is best described as what?

Difficulty: Medium

Correct Answer: Dilatant, rheopectic fluid

Explanation:


Introduction:
Some complex fluids display both rate-dependent and time-dependent viscosity changes. Correct classification of combined behaviors is important in diagnosing mixing problems (e.g., overloading agitators or poor dispersion) and choosing appropriate processing conditions.


Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Apparent viscosity increases as stirrer speed rises (instantaneous rate effect).
  • At roughly constant shear, apparent viscosity also increases with elapsed mixing time (time effect).
  • Temperature and composition are stable during the observation window.


Concept / Approach:
Shear-rate thickening is termed dilatancy: viscosity rises with increasing shear rate. Time-dependent thickening under constant shear is called rheopexy. A material exhibiting both simultaneously is therefore dilatant and rheopectic. Pseudoplastic and thixotropic describe rate-thinning and time-thinning, respectively, which contradict the stated trends. Newtonian fluids show neither rate nor time dependence beyond trivial effects.


Step-by-Step Solution:
From the rate effect alone (viscosity ↑ with speed), identify dilatant behavior.From the time effect alone (viscosity ↑ with time at constant shear), identify rheopectic behavior.Combine both to classify the fluid as dilatant, rheopectic.


Verification / Alternative check:
Plot apparent viscosity versus shear rate to confirm thickening; perform a three-interval rheological test at fixed shear to confirm time-dependent increase. Recovery tests after rest can reveal slow structural buildup consistent with rheopexy.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:

  • (a) Newtonian: viscosity independent of rate and time.
  • (b) Pseudoplastic + thixotropic: both thinning trends, opposite to observation.
  • (d) Contradictory pair (dilatant + pseudoplastic) mixes opposing rate behaviors.
  • (e) Yield-stress models address onset of flow, not the described rate/time thickening.


Common Pitfalls:
Confusing thixotropy with pseudoplasticity; attributing thermal rise to rheopexy; overlooking particle–particle structure buildup that can cause time-thickening in concentrated suspensions.


Final Answer:
Dilatant, rheopectic fluid

More Questions from Fluid Flow

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion