In ODMG terminology, is a “bag” specifically a multiset collection type (allowing duplicates) rather than a generic name for any collection of literals or objects?

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: Does not apply — a bag is a specific multiset type, not any collection

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
ODMG defines several collection types: set (no duplicates, unordered), bag (duplicates allowed, unordered), list (ordered, duplicates allowed), and array (fixed-size, indexed). Precise terminology matters when specifying attribute domains and reasoning about multiplicity and duplicates.



Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Collections can contain either literals or (in some contexts) object references depending on the declaration.
  • “Bag” has a formal meaning: an unordered multiset allowing duplicate elements.
  • The statement claims “bag” is a generic term for any collection.



Concept / Approach:
Choose the collection type based on semantics. If duplicates are meaningful and order is irrelevant, a bag is appropriate. If duplicates should be prevented, use a set. If order matters, use a list. Using correct types enables the DBMS and tooling to enforce intended constraints.



Step-by-Step Solution:
Identify multiplicity and ordering requirements for an attribute.Map those requirements: set (unique, unordered), bag (duplicate, unordered), list (ordered), array (indexed).Declare the attribute with the exact collection type that matches behavior.Test with sample data to ensure duplicates/order are handled as intended.Document the rationale for the chosen collection type.



Verification / Alternative check:
ODMG documentation specifies distinct semantics for each collection kind; “bag” is not a catch-all label.



Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Option b generalizes incorrectly. Options c and d try to restrict bags to either objects or literals; bags can hold elements of a declared element type regardless. Option e confuses collections with relationships.



Common Pitfalls:
Accidentally using a bag when uniqueness is required; relying on application code to remove duplicates instead of choosing a set; misunderstanding that order is undefined in bags.



Final Answer:
Does not apply — a bag is a specific multiset type, not any collection

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion