Hidden features and dimensions: Should drafters avoid placing dimensions to hidden lines and instead use visible or section views whenever possible?
-
ACorrect
-
BIncorrect
-
COnly correct for sheet metal
-
DOnly correct for assemblies
Answer
Correct Answer: Correct
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Hidden lines indicate features not visible in a given view. Dimensioning to hidden lines is discouraged because it invites misinterpretation and suggests the view is not the best place to communicate that size or location. Instead, use a view where the feature is visible or create a section or auxiliary view.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- A feature exists that is not visible in the current view (e.g., a hole, pocket, or internal step).
- Additional views or a section can be created.
- Goal is clarity and reduced inspection/fabrication errors.
Concept / Approach:Dimensioning to hidden geometry increases clutter and may confuse readers. Best practice is to show the feature where it appears in true shape—often via a section view—then place dimensions there. This reveals edges, surfaces, and relationships clearly.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Identify that the needed feature is hidden in the current view.Create an additional view (section/auxiliary) where the feature is visible and true.Place all relevant size and location dimensions on that clear view.Remove unnecessary hidden-line dimensions from the original view to reduce clutter.Verification / Alternative check:Compare readability and interpretation time; the sectioned view with visible features allows immediate understanding, validating the convention.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Incorrect / Only for sheet metal / assemblies: The principle applies across materials and product types.Common Pitfalls:Leaving dimensions tied to hidden lines due to space constraints; failing to create a section view when needed; mixing dimensions of the same feature across multiple views.
Final Answer:Correct