Difficulty: Easy
Correct Answer: Assertion (A) is false, but Reason (R) is true.
Explanation:
Introduction / Context:
This Assertion and Reason question tests basic economic geography and trade awareness in South Asia. It focuses on Bangladesh and India, two major countries in the global jute economy. The task is to judge the truth values of both statements and then decide whether the Reason logically explains the Assertion. This type of question frequently appears in general knowledge and competitive examinations to assess conceptual clarity about regional trade patterns.
Given Data / Assumptions:
Concept / Approach:
To solve Assertion and Reason questions, we follow a two step approach. First, we independently check whether Assertion (A) is factually correct. Second, we check whether Reason (R) is factually correct. Only after that do we examine whether Reason (R) logically explains why Assertion (A) is true. If Assertion (A) itself is not correct, then Reason (R) cannot be its correct explanation, even if Reason (R) is true on its own. In this case, we must recall the general direction of jute trade between India and Bangladesh.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Step 1: Bangladesh is widely known as one of the largest producers of raw jute in the world and is also a major exporter of raw jute and jute goods.
Step 2: India is also a very important jute producer, but India has a large domestic demand for packaging and other uses, so it often imports raw jute from Bangladesh to feed its own mills.
Step 3: Therefore, the net flow of jute trade is generally from Bangladesh to India, not from India to Bangladesh. Thus, Assertion (A), which claims that Bangladesh imports jute from India, is false.
Step 4: Reason (R) states that Bangladesh has most of the jute mills. Bangladesh indeed has a significant jute manufacturing sector with many mills and a strong export industry in jute goods, so Reason (R) is broadly true as a statement about the structure of its jute industry.
Step 5: Since Assertion (A) is false but Reason (R) is true, Reason (R) cannot be the correct explanation of Assertion (A). The correct pattern is A false, R true.
Verification / Alternative check:
Standard school geography texts and exam oriented reference books repeatedly describe Bangladesh as a leading producer and exporter of raw jute. India is usually shown as an importer of raw jute from Bangladesh to run its jute mills. This confirms that the direction mentioned in Assertion (A) is incorrect. At the same time, discussion of the jute industry in Bangladesh highlights the presence of many mills processing jute into bags, carpets, and other goods, supporting Reason (R).
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Options stating that both Assertion (A) and Reason (R) are true cannot be correct because Assertion (A) does not match the usual trade pattern. Options that claim both are false are also incorrect because Reason (R) is essentially true. It is also not correct to say that A is true and R is false, because A is the part that fails the fact check.
Common Pitfalls:
Learners sometimes assume that any two neighbouring producers must import from one another, without checking who is the larger exporter. Another mistake is to decide the relationship between A and R before independently checking the truth of each statement. Always remember that in Assertion and Reason questions, you must first judge truth, then explanation.
Final Answer:
Assertion (A) is false, but Reason (R) is true, so the correct option is Assertion (A) is false, but Reason (R) is true.
Discussion & Comments