Dimensioning policy for assemblies: As a rule, assembly drawings are usually not fully dimensioned; only key overall, interface, and fit dimensions are shown, while individual part dimensions appear on detail drawings. Assess this statement.

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: Correct: assemblies show limited critical dimensions, not full detail

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
Drawing packages typically include both assembly and detail drawings. Knowing which dimensions belong where improves clarity and avoids duplication or contradiction. Assemblies emphasize relationships and fits; details carry complete manufacturing information for each part.


Given Data / Assumptions:

  • We are discussing production documentation, not conceptual schematics.
  • Detail drawings exist for manufactured components.
  • Assemblies must communicate how parts relate and interface.


Concept / Approach:
Assembly drawings focus on mating conditions, reference datums, installation envelopes, overall size, and critical interfaces (bolt circles, clearances, shaft-to-bore fits). Detail drawings (or model-based definition) provide all feature sizes, tolerances, and finishes for individual parts. This division of information prevents conflicting numbers and keeps the assembly sheet readable.


Step-by-Step Solution:

Identify which dimensions affect fit and overall interfaces; place those on the assembly.Move feature-level dimensions (holes, slots, chamfers) to the relevant detail drawing.Ensure the bill of materials and callouts connect assembly items to their details.


Verification / Alternative check:
Compare a fully dimensioned assembly to a best-practice assembly. The best-practice version is cleaner, with only key dimensions, while the part details contain exhaustive size and tolerance data.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:

  • Putting every part dimension on the assembly (option B) creates clutter and conflicts.
  • Asserting “no dimensions at all” (option C) ignores necessary installation and fit dimensions.
  • Parts lists (option D) are not a place for numeric geometry.
  • Exploded views (option E) are pictorial aids, not the home for all dimensions.


Common Pitfalls:
Duplicating dimensions across assembly and detail sheets; omitting critical interface tolerances; failing to note reference datums that drive assembly inspection.


Final Answer:
Correct: assemblies show limited critical dimensions, not full detail

More Questions from Working Drawings

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion