Can you perform addition and subtraction using only bitwise operations (e.g., XOR, AND, NOT) without using the + or - operators?

Difficulty: Medium

Correct Answer: Yes — use XOR for sum without carry and AND/shift for carry; iterate until carry is zero

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
Bitwise-only addition and subtraction are classic algorithmic exercises that illuminate how CPUs implement arithmetic at the gate level. Understanding this helps in interviews, cryptography, embedded programming, and when implementing custom numeric types.


Given Data / Assumptions:

  • We want to compute a + b (or a - b) using bitwise operators.
  • We have XOR (^), AND (&), NOT (~), and shifts (<<, >>).
  • We assume fixed-width two’s-complement integers.


Concept / Approach:
The sum without carry is a ^ b. The carry bits are (a & b) << 1. Repeating this process by setting a = a ^ b and b = (old_a & old_b) << 1 and iterating until b becomes 0 yields the final sum in a. Subtraction a - b can be achieved by adding a to the two’s-complement of b, i.e., a + (~b + 1). This demonstrates that addition and subtraction can be built from bitwise operations alone.


Step-by-Step Solution:

Initialize: sum = a ^ b; carry = (a & b) << 1.While carry != 0: temp = sum; sum = sum ^ carry; carry = (temp & carry) << 1.When carry is 0, sum holds a + b.For subtraction, compute a + (~b + 1) using the same loop.


Verification / Alternative check:
Test with small values (e.g., a = 5, b = 3). The method converges to 8 without ever using + directly for the final arithmetic (except in forming ~b + 1, which itself can be built with the same loop).


Why Other Options Are Wrong:

“No — arithmetic operators are mandatory”: Incorrect; the bitwise method is standard.“Possible only for unsigned char” or “Only in assembly”: The approach is portable across integer widths and works in C/C++.“Division and modulo required”: Not needed.


Common Pitfalls:
Forgetting to loop until carry is zero; mixing signed and unsigned without understanding overflow rules.


Final Answer:
Yes — use XOR for sum without carry and AND/shift for carry; iterate until carry is zero.

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion