Classifying refractories by basicity: which of the following is NOT a basic refractory material?
-
AChrome-magnesite
-
BMagnesite
-
CDolomite
-
DSilicon carbide
-
EMagnesia-spinel
Answer
Correct Answer: Silicon carbide
Explanation
Introduction:Refractories are often categorized as acidic, basic, or neutral depending on their behavior with slags. Correct classification avoids deleterious reactions in service and premature wear.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Basic refractories: MgO-rich systems such as magnesite, dolomite, chrome-magnesite.
- Neutral refractories: silicon carbide, carbon, alumina in certain contexts.
- Service with basic slags typically needs basic refractories.
Concept / Approach:MgO and CaO bearing refractories are basic. Silicon carbide is generally classed as neutral (chemically stable to both acidic and basic slags to a degree) and not “basic.”
Step-by-Step Solution:List basic candidates: magnesite, chrome-magnesite, dolomite (MgO/CaO systems) → basic.Evaluate SiC: considered neutral, not basic.Thus, “Silicon carbide” is the item that is not basic.
Verification / Alternative check:Textbook tables place SiC among neutral refractories, known for high thermal conductivity and oxidation sensitivity at very high temperatures.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Chrome-magnesite, magnesite, dolomite, and magnesia-spinel are classic basic systems designed for basic slags.
Common Pitfalls:Assuming “neutral” equals “acidic” or “basic”; neutral refractories have distinct behavior and compatibility ranges.
Final Answer:Silicon carbide