logo

CuriousTab

CuriousTab

Discussion


Home Logical Reasoning Statement and Argument Comments

  • Question
  • Statement: Should there be a complete ban on manufacture and use of firecrackers?

    Arguments:

    1. No. This will render thousands of workers jobless.
    2. Yes. The firecracker manufacturers use child labour to a large extent.
    3. Yes. This will be a concrete step to reduce noise and air pollution.
    4. No. Use of firecrackers makes certain special occasions more lively and joyful.


  • Options
  • A. Only I and II are strong
  • B. Only I and III are strong
  • C. Only III and IV are strong
  • D. Only I, II and III are strong
  • E. Only I, III and IV are strong

  • Correct Answer
  • Only I and III are strong 

    Explanation
    Clearly, banning a product would surely render jobless the large number of workers involved in manufacturing it. Besides, firecrackers on burning produce explosive sounds and immense poisonous fumes, which cause both air and noise pollution. So, both arguments I and HI hold. However, to stop child labour, it is not necessary to close down the industry but strict laws against child abuse should be enforced and legal actions taken. Similarly, there are many other ways to make parties boisterous and special events enjoyable. Hence, II as well as IV does not hold strong.

  • Statement and Argument problems


    Search Results


    • 1. Statement: Should India acquire/manufacture the latest nuclear weapons?

      Arguments:

      1. Yes. The enemies of India are improving their weapons continuously and it becomes imperative to protect the sovereignty and integrity of the country.
      2. No. Instead the money should be diverted to development activities.
      3. No. The international community will isolate Indians and this will bring a setback to Indian economy.
      4. No. It will be against our policy of maintaining world peace.


    • Options
    • A. Only I is strong
    • B. Only I and IV are strong
    • C. Only I, II and IV are strong
    • D. All are strong
    • E. None of these
    • Discuss
    • 2. Statement: Should the system of Lok Adalats and mobile courts be encouraged in India?

      Arguments:

      1. Yes. It helps to grant speedy justice to the masses.
      2. Yes. The dispensing of minor cases at this level would reduce the burden on the higher courts.
      3. No. These courts are usually partial in justice.


    • Options
    • A. Only I and II are strong
    • B. Only II and III are strong
    • C. Only I and III are strong
    • D. All are strong
    • E. Only I is strong
    • Discuss
    • 3. Statement: Should all the management institutes in the country be brought under government control?

      Arguments:

      1. No. The government does not have adequate resources to run such institutes effectively.
      2. No. Each institute should be given freedom to function on its own.
      3. Yes. This will enable to have standardized education for all the students.
      4. Yes. Only then the quality of education would be improved.


    • Options
    • A. None is strong
    • B. Only I, II and III are strong
    • C. Only I and III are strong
    • D. All are strong
    • E. Only III is strong
    • Discuss
    • 4. Statement: Should the income generated out of agricultural activities be taxed?

      Arguments:

      1. No. Farmers are otherwise suffering from natural calamities and low yield coupled with low procurement price and their income should not be taxed.
      2. Yes. Majority of the population is dependent on agriculture and hence their income should be taxed to augment the resources.
      3. Yes. Many big farmers earn much more than the majority of the service earners and they should be taxed to remove the disparity.


    • Options
    • A. Only I is strong
    • B. Only I and II are strong
    • C. Only II and III are strong
    • D. All are strong
    • E. None of these
    • Discuss
    • 5. Statement: Should there be a complete ban on genetically modified imported seeds?

      Arguments:

      1. Yes. This will boost the demand of domestically developed seeds.
      2. No. This is the only way to increase production substantially.
      3. Yes. Genetically modified products will adversely affect the health of those who consume these products.


    • Options
    • A. Only I and II are strong
    • B. Only II is strong
    • C. Only II and III are strong
    • D. Only I and III are strong
    • E. All are strong
    • Discuss
    • 6. Statement: Should "literacy" be the minimum criterion for becoming a voter in India?

      Arguments:

      1. No. Mere literacy is no guarantee of political maturity of an individual.
      2. Yes. Illiterate people are less likely to make politically wiser decisions of voting for a right candidate or party.
      3. No. Voting is the constitutional right of every citizen.


    • Options
    • A. None is strong
    • B. Only I and II are strong
    • C. Only III is strong
    • D. Only II and III are strong
    • E. All are strong
    • Discuss
    • 7. Statement: Should there be only few banks in place of numerous smaller banks in India?

      Arguments:

      1. Yes. This will help secure the investor's money as these big banks will be able to withstand intermittent market related shocks.
      2. No. A large number of people will lose their jobs as after the merger many employees will be redundant.
      3. Yes. This will help consolidate the entire banking industry and will lead to healthy competition.


    • Options
    • A. None is strong
    • B. Only I and II are strong
    • C. Only II and III are strong
    • D. Only I and III are strong
    • E. All are strong
    • Discuss
    • 8. Statement: Should religion be taught in our schools?

      Arguments:

      1. No. Ours is a secular state.
      2. Yes. Teaching religion helps inculcate moral values among children.
      3. No. How can one dream of such a step when we want the young generation to fulfil its role in the 21st century.


    • Options
    • A. All are strong
    • B. None is strong
    • C. Only I is strong
    • D. Only II is strong
    • E. Only I and III are strong
    • Discuss
    • 9. Statement: Should the parliamentary elections in India be held every three years as against five years at present?

      Arguments:

      1. No. This will enhance wastage of money and resources.
      2. Yes. This will help the voters to change non-performing representatives without much delay.
      3. No. The elected representatives will not have enough time to settle and concentrate on developmental activities.


    • Options
    • A. None is strong
    • B. Only I and II are strong
    • C. Only II and III are strong
    • D. Only I and III are strong
    • E. All are strong
    • Discuss
    • 10. Statement: Should the number of holidays of government employees be reduced?

      Arguments:

      1. Yes. Our government employees are having the maximum number of holidays among the countries of the world.
      2. Yes. It is a sign of British legacy, why should we carry it further?
      3. Yes. It will speed up work and all the pending jobs can be completed well in time.
      4. No. Employees must be given ample spare time to spend with their family.


    • Options
    • A. Only I and III are strong
    • B. Only III is strong
    • C. Only I, III and IV are strong
    • D. None is strong
    • E. None of these
    • Discuss


    Comments

    There are no comments.

Enter a new Comment