Difficulty: Easy
Correct Answer: Sugarcane
Explanation:
Introduction / Context:
This question links basic plant biology with agriculture. Different crops use different photosynthetic pathways, such as C3 and C4, which affect their efficiency under high light, temperature and low carbon dioxide conditions. Understanding which crops have higher photosynthetic efficiency is important in agronomy, crop selection and questions related to food security and bioenergy.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- The crops listed are sugarcane, wheat, cotton and rice.
- We are asked which crop has the highest photosynthetic activity, which essentially refers to photosynthetic efficiency in converting light energy into biomass.
- We assume typical tropical or subtropical field conditions where high light intensity and warm temperatures favour certain photosynthetic pathways.
Concept / Approach:
Plants are broadly classified as C3 or C4 based on their carbon fixation pathway. C4 plants, such as sugarcane and maize, possess a special mechanism that concentrates CO2 in bundle sheath cells, minimising photorespiration and improving efficiency under high light and temperature. C3 plants, like wheat, rice and cotton, are more prone to photorespiration under such conditions, reducing their effective photosynthetic efficiency. Among the given options, sugarcane is a well known C4 crop with very high photosynthetic efficiency, which is why it is often used for sugar and biofuel production.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Step 1: Classify the crops by photosynthetic pathway: sugarcane is a C4 plant, while wheat, cotton and rice are primarily C3 plants.
Step 2: Recall that C4 plants have higher photosynthetic efficiency under high light, high temperature and low CO2 conditions due to their CO2 concentrating mechanism.
Step 3: Recognise that sugarcane is often cited in textbooks as an example of a crop with very high photosynthetic activity and productivity.
Step 4: Wheat, rice and cotton are important crops but do not match sugarcane in maximum photosynthetic efficiency per unit leaf area.
Step 5: Therefore, among the options, sugarcane is the correct choice for highest photosynthetic activity.
Verification / Alternative check:
Agricultural data and plant physiology references show that C4 crops such as sugarcane and maize typically achieve higher yields of biomass per unit of intercepted light compared with C3 cereals under warm, sunny conditions. Sugarcane in particular is used as a model crop for high productivity and is a major source of sucrose and ethanol. Wheat and rice, despite being staple food grains, are C3 plants and have lower maximum photosynthetic rates under similar conditions. Cotton is mainly grown for fibre and is also a C3 plant without the C4 advantage.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Wheat: A C3 cereal crop; its photosynthetic efficiency is lower than that of C4 crops like sugarcane under high light and temperature.
Cotton: A C3 plant grown for its fibre, not known for the highest photosynthetic efficiency compared with C4 crops.
Rice: Another C3 staple cereal, very important for food but not as efficient as sugarcane in photosynthesis under the specified conditions.
Common Pitfalls:
Students may associate high productivity only with cereals like rice and wheat because of their importance in diets, overlooking the role of sugarcane as a highly productive biomass and sugar crop. Another pitfall is to forget or confuse which crops are C3 versus C4. To avoid such errors, remember that sugarcane, maize and sorghum are classical C4 crops with high photosynthetic efficiency, while wheat and rice are C3 cereals.
Final Answer:
The crop with the highest photosynthetic activity among the options is sugarcane.
Discussion & Comments